In late 2006, we made a bunch of Angry Faic shirts and sold them with a simple Paypal checkout.
The response was good, so we decided to go totally nuts with building a dedicated Newgrounds store. The project defeated two programmers before Rob finally made it happen in 2008 and the store officially launched. We made shirts, toys, stickers, posters and keychains. Bob initially handled order fulfillment and customer service, then Luis took over after Bob.
By March of 2014, Luis was transitioning to a new job, Rob was no longer on the team, the store wasn't moving a lot of merch, there were some bugs and the small remaining staff didn't want to be distracted by it anymore. We decided it was time to call it quits.
Two weeks' notice was given and we actually managed to sell most of the remaining inventory. What remains will be given out as prizes and gifts to future NG contributors.
For posterity, here is an archive of every item ever available in the store:
T-Shirts and Apparel
Angry Clock Shirt
Angry Faic Shirt
Anusboy Shirt
Awesome Shirt
Badly Drawn Dog Shirt
Bitey Leap Shirt
Bitey Portrait Shirt
Blockhead Shirt
Brackenwood Shirt
Cuboy Shirt
Dad 'n Me Shirt
Dandy Shirt
Dr. Fetus Shirt
Falconry Shirt
Happy Clock Shirt
Happy Wheels Shirt
Kenstar Shirt
Ladies Bitey Shirt
Ladies Classic Fit NG Shirt
Ladies Tank-Top NG Shirt
Madness Error Shirt
Madness Hank Shirt
Madness Splatter Shirt
Mastermind Shirt
Meat Boy Shirt
Nameless Shirt
NG Explosion Shirt
NG Logo Shirt
NG UK Shirt
O-Face Shirt
Pico Shirt
Retarded Animal Babies Shirt
Sketchbook Tour 2008 Shirt
Sketchbook Tour 2009 Shirt
Tankmen Chase Shirt
Tankmen Parachute Shirt
Tankmen Smoking Shirt
Toys & Collectible Items
Alien Hominid Plush
Angry Faic Keychain
Dad 'n Me Keychain
Dad 'n Me Plush
Dr. Shroud Figurine
MindChamber Patch
Mystery Box
Newgrounds Writing Anthology
Not So Mysterious Box
O-Face Keychain
Penicorn
Reincarnation Demon
Tank Keychain
Tank Patch Pack
Tankman Figurine
Time Fcuk Plush
Castle Crashers Collectibles
You can still buy many of these and much more at the Behemoth store.
Barbarian
Blue Knight
Castle Crashers 4-Pack
Chicken Charm Pack
Giraffey Charm Pack
Green Knight
King Figure
Knight Keychain
Orange Knight
Pazzo Charm Pack
Pink Knight
Red Knight
Squeezy Chicken
Artist Discs
Alert DVD
Broken Saints DVD
Clabtrap Rap Battle 2012 Album
College University Season 1 DVD
College University Season 2 DVD
Dr. Shroud DVD
Hip-Hop Compo 2010 Double Album
Hip-Hop Compo 2011 Double Album
John's Arm DVD
Kingbastard Album - 713D UP 70 M4CH1N35
Kingbastard Album - Beautiful Isolation
Larry and the Gnomes Soundtrack
Marcus Peblo DVD
Modem Album
Neurotically Yours 1 DVD
Neurotically Yours 2 DVD
Neurotically Yours 3 DVD
Onward to Calgary DVD
Paladin DVD
Retarded Animal Babies DVD
Sick Animation CD
Sorohanro Album
Snowy the Frostman DVD
Super Meat Boy Game
This is a Cry For Help
This is a Cry For Help - Signed!
Stickers and Posters
1976 Comic
1976 Comic Issue #2
1976 Comic Issue #3
Angry Faic Stickers
Beatles Poster
Dr. Fetus Stickers
Emote Stickers
Meat Boy Stickers
Newave Poster
Newgrounds Poster
NG Calendar 2009
NG Calendar 2010
NG Calendar 2011
NG Calendar 2012
NG Calendar 2013
NG Logo Stickers
NG Poster 3-Pack
Madness Poster
Murshaq Poster
One Shot Comic
Physeter Poster
Pico Stickers
Red Baron Poster
Saga of the Dead Poster
Super Meat Boy Comic
Tankmen Stickers
Finally, the store was the original place to buy Supporter Upgrades, which remain available under their own system.