This is just the type of place I was looking for, and im suprised people out there actually like to review. heres my latest greatest flash, because im needy and like to have loads of reviews. :P http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/43 1521awesome idea, now time for me to do the same.

At 3/30/08 09:14 AM, jxl180 wrote: Please review my audio:

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1 32420

Thank you!

I don't mean to sound like an ass, but I believe you might of forgot about mine.

Domo Arigato,
jxl180

Please review this audio piece.

It's a bed-time pop ballad, so I don't expect any hardcore techno stuff.

REMEMBER ME?!?!?
lol any1 remember fun with drums?
HERES NUMBA 2!!!
plz reviewW0000T!!!

Guys... where's the list with the requests? It usually comes Sunday, but I've seen it Monday once. But it's already Tuesday, and no signs of it.

Anyone knows where's milinko?

At 4/1/08 12:56 PM, Sir-Nuts wrote: Guys... where's the list with the requests? It usually comes Sunday, but I've seen it Monday once. But it's already Tuesday, and no signs of it.

Anyone knows where's milinko?

No sign of him :(

I guess someone else should take over (at least for this week).
Maybe I can do it tomorrow or on Thursday, if not someone else has already done it until then.

Has anyone PMd him?

At 4/1/08 03:01 PM, Haggard wrote:

Anyone knows where's milinko?

No sign of him :(

I guess someone else should take over (at least for this week).
Maybe I can do it tomorrow or on Thursday, if not someone else has already done it until then.

As list updates go, this one seems reasonably easy to perform. My main issue is that I won't be able to update on this week, as it's Birthday season in 1 1/2 hours time, with 6 birthdays and one Wedding Anniversary in the next 15 days. Fortunately, one of those is my own and they're all on different days, so it keeps me active :P

He posted today so he's alive at least and has internet access. Seems impolite (and a waste of time) to update if he's already started. We should at least give him a while to reply.

If anyone did have the foresight to PM him earlier than within the past 1/2 hour, I'll try to do this update before bed. (I've never used a digital spreadsheet before and aren't sure how long the process will take me).

What's everyone's opinion - wait/update?

On a separate note, I reckon the list of submissions/list of reviewers should be 2 separate updates.

At 4/1/08 05:46 PM, Bezman wrote: He posted today so he's alive at least and has internet access. Seems impolite (and a waste of time) to update if he's already started. We should at least give him a while to reply.

I agree, if he's not gonna do it at all he probably would of told us he didnt have time.

If anyone did have the foresight to PM him earlier than within the past 1/2 hour, I'll try to do this update before bed. (I've never used a digital spreadsheet before and aren't sure how long the process will take me).

What's everyone's opinion - wait/update?

On a separate note, I reckon the list of submissions/list of reviewers should be 2 separate updates.

2 Seperate updates? To make it easier? Is it not simpler to have it all at once as the submissions isnt that difficult so no sense putting it on its own. I think we should wait till tomorrow, or at least a PM reply.

At 4/1/08 06:12 PM, Shadow-1409 wrote: 2 Seperate updates? To make it easier? Is it not simpler to have it all at once as the submissions isnt that difficult so no sense putting it on its own.

Well, each week we need to review all requests made between the previous list of requests and the current update of reviewers. So if they're posted together, you could end up having less than a week to listen to the audio, which I personally don't think is enough time.

Disregarding this particular situation, I think it'd make sense to maybe post the list of requests on Saturday (or Friday even) and the reviewers on Sunday (or Monday). That way, everyone would have slightly OVER a week to do reviews, not 'around' a week. I'm just thinking out loud, as in a month or so, Milinko's gonna be heading off and we'll have to take over the list ourselves.

Anyways, in this particular situation, I think it'd make even more sense to do the list of requests - otherwise a request made tomorrow would only have 3-4 days for us to listen to it. The fact that it's easy to do is surely an argment FOR doing it, not against.

Anyways, although I don't want to go against any of Milinko's wishes, I personally feel it'd be best to do the requests tonight and update the reviewer list tomorrow if he's unable to.

What does everyone else feel is appropriate?

I agree with Bezman, the update should be done around Friday or so. I was looking at the supposed requests for this week (as for March 30) and so far we have:

5 Flash requests:
ShortShakespeare- Othello
Office Christmas Party
NG Preloader: The Game2.5
Madness Byrd Dance
Spotlight submission: Scottoons Cat-a-pult

19 audio requests (but one of them have a messed up link and the other got deleted):

The Street Life
Space Elevator (S.C.)
Episode 1
Jxl180 - Heist
Dewy Embers (Mo-Tech
BlkAce: Mario Underground
WAKIWAI (DjD)
Ready for Action (Extended)
Ouroborus
(FMC) -=Muffins=-
Blue 42 -Redo
Perspiration
Cartoon
r18 - Element
Experimental Orchestra
+Astronaut's Waltz+

So if you want to start reviewing them, here they are.

At 4/1/08 08:05 PM, Sir-Nuts wrote: I agree with Bezman, the update should be done around Friday or so. I was looking at the supposed requests for this week (as for March 30) and so far we have:

If milinko is doing an update this week, it's certainly collated the information where he wants and needs it - all together there. I might get a few of those done later on if it quietens down a little at my girlfriend's after the birthday celebrations have wound down a little.

At 4/1/08 06:51 PM, Bezman wrote: Anyways, although I don't want to go against any of Milinko's wishes, I personally feel it'd be best to do the requests tonight and update the reviewer list tomorrow if he's unable to.

What does everyone else feel is appropriate?

I kinda like the idea of two seperated lists and I think it's worth a try. I also think that milinko surely don't want to abandon this place now that it's running so fine and because of that I believe he wouldn't have anything against one of us doing the update.

Please I would like more reviews for this - http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/41 7012

Would love some feedback on my newest, unfinished, song.
Halloween(unfinished)

-Greatfaith-

I was just thinking that it'd be funny if Milinko wanted to show us the need for a contingency plan.

I mean, he's pretty reliable (or has been thus far) but the successors might not be. To avoid similar problems when he leaves and someone else is doing the list, it might be an idea to always have a 'vice list-maintainer' who would do the list if it were more than half a day late (with no notification in this thread).

I suppose if the review/requester lists were to be kept separate, there could be 2 people doing the lists anyway, and the guy doing one would do the other if necessary (as a fall back plan).

Anyways, I'm gonna try to do the list within the next 1-14ish hours. I haven't heard back, but it has been over 24hrs.

Dammit, I finally got some free time on my hands and I was looking to do the submissions for this week, but there sadly are none. But I've noticed you guys were talking about doing the list yourselves? Nice idea, and if you need any help I'd be happy to give you a hand. Just send a PM. I'm bored as hell anyway.

I started the list but won't be able to finish it until late tonight (GMT). I hadn't used Excel before and it was perhaps a mistake to try and learn it.

If anyone has time to spare, feel free to do it yourself before then.

At 4/2/08 08:37 PM, AnalPenguinFarming wrote: Dammit, I finally got some free time on my hands and I was looking to do the submissions for this week, but there sadly are none.

Yes, there are: Sir-Nuts posted them ;) .

And you are always free to look through the posts for requests and review them BEFORE they go onto the "requests for this week"-list ;) .

The Street Life(ft. The Notorious B.I.G.)

General Rules for New Reviewers
If you are planning on completing requests, please do the following:
-Post in this thread to let us know you plan on reviewing.
-Understand the points system and keep track of your own score. From now on, I will only add you to the list if you post your own score after the first week.

General Rules for Requesters
If you are planning on requesting review, please do the following:
-I will post no more than 3 requests from a single user in one week.
-Due to the points system, you may not see reviews until up to two weeks after you request.
-Post a direct link to the submission(s) you want reviewed.
-DO NOT request without putting a link, I don't have the time or patience to get the links myself.
-DO NOT say "Review everything" for the same reason above.
-DO NOT request the same submission more than once.
-Please do us a favor and respond to reviews if you request them.

A list of requests was posted by Sir-Nuts.

Points:
**Please also keep track of your own points. If you see something missing, I probably made a mistake**
**To be on the list, you must make at least one review, posters only will not be counted**
5 points for a review on a requested movie/game
7 points for a review on a requested audio
+1 point for putting "Review Request Club" at the bottom of a requested review
3 points for posting at least once throughout the week
5 points for referring a new member (must mention you in first post)
7 points for reviewing all requests for that week

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
1. 4051 | 549/623 | 088.12% | 19/19 | Coop83
2. 3360 | 493/658 | 074.92% | 00/19 | milinko959
3. 2334 | 301/301 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Little-Rena
4. 2112 | 283/283 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Haggard
5. 1921 | 263/279 | 094.27% | 19/19 | Shanus
6. 1672 | 234/275 | 085.09% | 00/19 | NintendoMadness
7. 1582 | 222/663 | 033.48% | 19/19 | Bezman
8. 1222 | 173/655 | 026.41% | 01/19 | Imacow
9. 1197 | 186/228 | 081.58% | 01/19 | Cyberdevil
10. 995 | 133/173 | 076.87% | 03/19 | WritersBlock
11. 915 | 117/190 | 061.58% | 02/17 | Jurian
12. 703 | 091/248 | 036.69% | 11/19 | AnalPenguinFarming
13. 555 | 075/265 | 028.30% | 03/19 | Sir-Nuts
14. 488 | 057/246 | 023.17% | 00/19 | aldlv
15. 482 | 062/066 | 093.94% | 15/19 | Shadow-1409
16. 412 | 051/192 | 026.56% | 01/19 | LilFugitive
17. 363 | 044/128 | 034.38% | 02/19 | Suspended-3rd-Chord
18. 325 | 046/490 | 009.39% | 00/19 | Auz
19. 212 | 027/178 | 015.17% | 00/19 | Ragnarokia
20. 207 | 024/079 | 030.38% | 00/18 | GronmonSE
21. 184 | 025/044 | 056.82% | 01/19 | mac2130
22. 166 | 022/028 | 078.57% | 14/19 | PicosGhost
23. 075 | 012/083 | 014.46% | 00/19 | yoshi77777
24. 068 | 011/084 | 013.10% | 00/19 | Bearkillr
25. 065 | 014/044 | 031.82% | 05/19 | cristianedu
26. 011 | 001/019 | 005.26% | 01/19 | Mad-Muppet

Requests this week: 19
Total all time: 663
Review this Week: 155
Average per member: 5.96
Average per movie: 8.16

New To the List
Mad-Muppet

Leaving the List :(
Phantox

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Bezman

A lower average per movie, but higher average per member. Looks like the number of requests last week was a bit too much for the club... let's see how we fare this week!

Also, this update took me 2 hrs, 12 minutes. Bloody hell...

If Milinko still hasn't shown up, someone else will have to do it on Sunday/Monday. I'm happy to give you my excel files - maybe the calculations I had adding each row will help speed you up slightly.

At 4/1/08 01:54 PM, Murad136 wrote: I have revied a few submissions, I say so as it asks me to in one if milinko's posts.

It actually doesn't look like you reviewed any of the requests.

At 4/3/08 09:43 PM, Bezman wrote: Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
1. 4051 | 549/623 | 088.12% | 19/19 | Coop83

Thanks for the update, Bezman. I'm hoping to get all of the requests sorted in the next 36 hours, so that should a) keep me on the 100% club and b) Gain me access to the top 100 Audio Reviewers list.

This looks like a great little club. I don't fully understand the point system, nor do I really care about stats but I am going to look into help out people that would like to have their work reviewed in the future.

At 4/3/08 09:43 PM, Bezman wrote:

Very nice update, thanks a bunch!

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
3. 2334 | 301/301 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Little-Rena
4. 2112 | 283/283 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Haggard
5. 1921 | 263/279 | 094.27% | 19/19 | Shanus

Well, nothing new here...

6. 1672 | 234/275 | 085.09% | 00/19 | NintendoMadness
7. 1582 | 222/663 | 033.48% | 19/19 | Bezman

Uh oh, NM is still MIA? Looks like Bezman is going to pass him again! :)

New To the List
Mad-Muppet

Hi!

Leaving the List :(
Phantox

Well, he asked for it (literally), so good bye to you!

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Bezman

A very small party this time...

Review this Week: 155
Average per member: 5.96
Average per movie: 8.16

A lower average per movie, but higher average per member. Looks like the number of requests last week was a bit too much for the club... let's see how we fare this week!

Yeah, average per member is very low this week, but average per movie is still quite good!

Also, this update took me 2 hrs, 12 minutes. Bloody hell...

Again, thank you very much!

At 4/3/08 09:43 PM, Bezman wrote:

A list of requests was posted by Sir-Nuts.

Hehe...

Thanks for the update, Bezman! Better late than never.

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User

13. 555 | 075/265 | 028.30% | 03/19 | Sir-Nuts

I'm still slacking... I'll try to change this scenery tonight.

New To the List
Mad-Muppet

Hello there!

Leaving the List :(
Phantox

He's more of a BBS poster now... Goodbye!

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Bezman

Congratulations!

A lower average per movie, but higher average per member. Looks like the number of requests last week was a bit too much for the club... let's see how we fare this week!

Let's see what will happen. But I have a question: when will the next update come? Because not everyone will be able to complete every request within 2 1/2 days...

Also, this update took me 2 hrs, 12 minutes. Bloody hell...

Wow...

If Milinko still hasn't shown up, someone else will have to do it on Sunday/Monday. I'm happy to give you my excel files - maybe the calculations I had adding each row will help speed you up slightly.

I have another question: has anyone here already PMed milinko?

15. 482 | 062/066 | 093.94% | 15/19 | Shadow-1409

Dude what the hell, do me a favor and re check because i did every single one of the reviews, i just checked i did all 4 falsh and all 15 audio. >:(

Requests this week: 19
Total all time: 663
Review this Week: 155
Average per member: 5.96
Average per movie: 8.16

Not bad averages ^_^

New To the List
Mad-Muppet

Welcome to the club dude!!

Leaving the List :(
Phantox

Bye Phantox!

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Bezman

Congrats to all in here but i should be in here, double check sir nuts please

A lower average per movie, but higher average per member. Looks like the number of requests last week was a bit too much for the club... let's see how we fare this week!

Also, this update took me 2 hrs, 12 minutes. Bloody hell...

Wow, thanks for doing it though dude.

id like for you to check this again, im not too pissed as you had to do the list on short notice but i checked like 4 times and ive defo got em all done

At 4/4/08 03:19 PM, zimzap wrote: This looks like a great little club. I don't fully understand the point system, nor do I really care about stats but I am going to look into help out people that would like to have their work reviewed in the future.

I try my best too to not get hung-up about 'stats'.

Essentially, what you should concern yourself with is the weekly list of requests. Just review whatever you have time for from that list, making sure your feedback is useful.

Welcome to the club!

At 4/4/08 05:56 PM, Sir-Nuts wrote: Let's see what will happen. But I have a question: when will the next update come? Because not everyone will be able to complete every request within 2 1/2 days...

Well, I'm personally heading off on Sunday. I won't be doing any updates. I think it'll be safer to assume Milinko's not coming back in the near future.

Ultimately, the final decision is with whomever does the list, but it would be nice to democratise the process a bit.

Personally, I think the update should happen at the time we want it to happen each week - not letting last week's hiccup have a knock-on effect.

I'd suggest that someone who has spare time on Sunday/Monday volunteers to update the list. The list of submissions can be done by the same person or a different person.

Once an update has been done (roughly) on time, we can maybe sort out some contingency plan and try to instate some order.

Hrm... is anyone willing to volunteer to do the next update?

Though it took me over 2 hours, some of that time was spent typing up formulae in the excel calculator. I've uploaded my .txt and excel files here so it should save anyone at least 10-20 minutes..Someone who has used the program before could do it even faster. (I had never used it before.)

I have another question: has anyone here already PMed milinko?

Surely the question should be, 'has anyone here NOT already PMd Milinko?'

Frankly, if anyone still hasn't contacted the usual list maintainer after an unexplained absence of nearly a week, it doesn't bode well for how much regard they give Milinko. Seriously, if you care about him or his contributions, I'd suggest PMing if you haven't already.

At 4/4/08 06:18 PM, Shadow-1409 wrote: id like for you to check this again, im not too pissed as you had to do the list on short notice but i checked like 4 times and ive defo got em all done

I kept the excel file, so it wasn't too hard to check out. You're right so I updated and reposted the update.

I may well have made other mistakes - I suggest that anyone who cares about their score should double-check it and tell me if there's a mistake.

General Rules for New Reviewers
If you are planning on completing requests, please do the following:
-Post in this thread to let us know you plan on reviewing.
-Understand the points system and keep track of your own score. From now on, I will only add you to the list if you post your own score after the first week.

General Rules for Requesters
If you are planning on requesting review, please do the following:
-I will post no more than 3 requests from a single user in one week.
-Due to the points system, you may not see reviews until up to two weeks after you request.
-Post a direct link to the submission(s) you want reviewed.
-DO NOT request without putting a link, I don't have the time or patience to get the links myself.
-DO NOT say "Review everything" for the same reason above.
-DO NOT request the same submission more than once.
-Please do us a favor and respond to reviews if you request them.

A list of requests was posted by Sir-Nuts.

Points:
**Please also keep track of your own points. If you see something missing, I probably made a mistake**
**To be on the list, you must make at least one review, posters only will not be counted**
5 points for a review on a requested movie/game
7 points for a review on a requested audio
+1 point for putting "Review Request Club" at the bottom of a requested review
3 points for posting at least once throughout the week
5 points for referring a new member (must mention you in first post)
7 points for reviewing all requests for that week

Points | Stats | % rate | weekly| user
1. 4051 | 549/623 | 088.12% | 19/19 | Coop83
2. 3360 | 493/658 | 074.92% | 00/19 | milinko959
3. 2334 | 301/301 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Little-Rena
4. 2112 | 283/283 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Haggard
5. 1921 | 263/279 | 094.27% | 19/19 | Shanus
6. 1672 | 234/275 | 085.09% | 00/19 | NintendoMadness
7. 1582 | 222/663 | 033.48% | 19/19 | Bezman
8. 1222 | 173/655 | 026.41% | 01/19 | Imacow
9. 1197 | 186/228 | 081.58% | 01/19 | Cyberdevil
10. 995 | 133/173 | 076.87% | 03/19 | WritersBlock
11. 915 | 117/190 | 061.58% | 02/17 | Jurian
12. 703 | 091/248 | 036.69% | 11/19 | AnalPenguinFarming
13. 555 | 075/265 | 028.30% | 03/19 | Sir-Nuts
15. 521 | 066/066 | 100.00% | 19/19 | Shadow-1409
14. 488 | 057/246 | 023.17% | 00/19 | aldlv
16. 412 | 051/192 | 026.56% | 01/19 | LilFugitive
17. 363 | 044/128 | 034.38% | 02/19 | Suspended-3rd-Chord
18. 325 | 046/490 | 009.39% | 00/19 | Auz
19. 212 | 027/178 | 015.17% | 00/19 | Ragnarokia
20. 207 | 024/079 | 030.38% | 00/18 | GronmonSE
21. 184 | 025/044 | 056.82% | 01/19 | mac2130
22. 166 | 022/028 | 078.57% | 14/19 | PicosGhost
23. 075 | 012/083 | 014.46% | 00/19 | yoshi77777
24. 068 | 011/084 | 013.10% | 00/19 | Bearkillr
25. 065 | 014/044 | 031.82% | 05/19 | cristianedu
26. 011 | 001/019 | 005.26% | 01/19 | Mad-Muppet

Requests this week: 19
Total all time: 663
Review this Week: 155
Average per member: 5.96
Average per movie: 8.16

New To the List
Mad-Muppet

Leaving the List :(
Phantox

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Bezman, Shadow-1409

Maybe no-one cares, but for future reference, the stats weren't updated in the updated update.

These are the updated stats that weren't updated in the aforementioned updated update, but have now been updated for a mini-update. A post-update update, if you will.

An update to an update gone wrong.

Review this Week: 159
Average per member: 6.12
Average per movie: 8.37

Thanks for the multiple updates ^_^ noone can blame you for making a few slight errors as really none of us know exactly how to do it. I have a slight problem, the review list Nuts posted doesnt have every review requested on it i dont think so i just went ahead and reviewed everything from 4 pages back to make sure i have it all done, but now i dont know how many points ive amassed, so whoever is doing the list this week is gonna have to figure them out as i wasnt evtirely sure what to review, and also 2 of the requests have weird links, one is broken and the other seems to be deleted, so i reviewed everything in order to keep my 100%.
All my reviews are done now. And ive noticed that not many people have done any this week. Hmmm... I hope now Milinko seems to be gone people wont give up on the club. :(