At 7/8/11 11:23 PM, Blaze-Heatnix wrote:
I hated Fairly Odd Parents as a kid. Maybe I need to take a second look, because I always thought all the jokes were unfunny and episodes never ended properly and overstayed their welcome.
I liked it well enough when I was a kid, but I was never a big fan or anything. I think the humor was kind of strange for a kids' show at the time, with all the sarcasm and pop culture references and whatnot (of course, that's what almost all cartoons are like nowadays). Plus now I hold it partially accountable for the death of my beloved Invader Zim, so it's got that against it too. But still, I think some of the older episodes would hold up well to throwback viewing.
Also, for a little primary audience perspective: I work with eight and nine-year-olds, and when I asked some of them about their favorite cartoons, Fairly OddParents was one of the first shows they mentioned. Which struck me as really weird considering how old it is. But like I was saying before, maybe that style of cartoon is just more popular now.
I want to ask everybody here an important question: Completely ignoring that MLP:FIM is a meme, how many of you honestly think it's a great series? Nicely written, nicely animated, lots of charm?
Honestly, I just fail to understand how people can genuinely be fans of this show. And it's not because of the whole "it's supposed to be for little girls" thing, because we all know that's a stupid argument. For me, I just can't get over the fact that no matter how well-written, nicely animated, or charming the show is, at the end of the day it still exists as an ancillary marketing product of a toy company, created in a boardroom by a bunch of old guys in suits to help sell shit.
Maybe that's what passed for greatness in the '80s, but now we have two decades of creator-driven, artistically ambitious TV animation behind us, and my expectations are higher. From what I can tell, MLP superficially imitates the quality of those shows, but doesn't do much more than that. But that's just me. I'm not trying to say that whatever you guys see in this show isn't really there, just that I can't see it.
Anyway, I've been watching a lot of cartoons lately so I think I'm going to try to start posting more in this thread. I just finished Avatar: The Last Airbender yesterday and I'm still kind of processing it now, but maybe later I'll post something more substantial about it. For now I'll just say that I completely ignored the show when it first came out, but I was intrigued when the A.V. Club picked it as one of the shows they'd be doing write-ups on this summer, and it's now instantly become one of my all-time favorites. I highly recommend it to all of you who haven't watched it yet or saw some early episodes but didn't like it; the first half of the first season is kind of a slog, but everything after that is pure gold.
Oh, and while I'm at it, who else is excited for new Adventure Time tomorrow?