look honestly this is well made idle game and for a idle game it deserves at least 4 to 4.5 stars but i am not going to give it that because it does not do what its supposed to it fails as a idle game now now i know i seem contradictory but what you need to add is for it to play when you click off the tab then i can consider it a idle game and i will even rewrite my review for you if you add that also a idle game is supposed to be a idle player that plays while your doing something else i.e it plays in the backround anyway good game cant wait to see what else you make