00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

Our goal is for Newgrounds to be ad free for everyone! Become a Supporter today and help make this dream a reality!

Reviews for "The Guardian"

The game was good il give it that but when you get in front of that one villager and the 4 behind him are shaking i cant move AT ALL, i literally tryed every letter and number on my keyboard. some people are saying tht he climbed later on but i never experienced that, so thats why i gave it such a low rating, i made it higher cause i cant really make any so.... if this was rating based on it being a REAL game it wouldve been lower. Also the music has a long gap of nothing :/

Really good job.
Other say "slow", but you have done a nice job.
Really like it!

While the narrative was beautifully poignant and the grayscale pixel graphics were uniquely atmospheric, the execution was flawed. The excessive repetition of objectives, the lengthy intervals, and the overall linear nature basically prevent this from being a game at all - simply a story where you occasionally have to push a button to hear the next bit.

I believe this would have been better off as pure narrative - removing what semblance of interactivity there is and reducing the end product to an animation, or even just leaving it as a written story.

If you're going to make a game, you need to go all the way - there has to be some kind of interactivity beyond completing a simple objective to make the player feel needed, if you know what I mean. Even maintaining this format, it would've been possible - multiple conditions that the player could choose between, leading to one of a number of endings, that sort of thing.

It pains me to give this a rating as low as I am because it nearly brought tears to my eyes, but in the end, you need to pick between a film and a game - resting in the space between is playing the jack of all trades but master of none.

My Rating is 2.5 , because i dont like how the giant moves (SO SLOW) and how many times I have to go to the giant , and sometimes I have to wait for like 50 seconds..

its amazing what you can accomplish when you have the right story and mood. You don't need great graphics to make a great game. Well done. I will be looking out for more of you work.