00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

harkhan71 just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "TOME Episode 02"

For the second episode it works but improvement...

... is still worth considering.

I deeply apologize to you Chris. In my review of TOME Short: Hackers, I was somewhat concerned with you simply dumping a short a month after the first episode and I accused you of saying that it met your quota for the month. What happened was I didn't check your twitter feed (because apparently I'm the only freak in the world who doesn't use twitter) and didn't see you were hard at work with this episode until after I wrote my review.

My point however back then with the characters still stood.

However, this episode brought me exactly what I was looking for when I said I wanted some sort of character development and foreshadowing. Granted the only thing I learned about Gamecrazed is that he's got a noble heart, but that's a start compared to simply being "the stoic." (Although that's sort of a given since he's one of the heroes.)

We're given foreshadowing on an event most TTA veterans will be looking forward to, but we're given tight lips about it so those that have not seen the original series will be certainly pleased when the event comes.

I do have a few concerns though, some of them are minor, others might alienate the audience, and the rest is simply stuff that can be considered.

As far as story is concerned, the whole "Are you Doubling's sister?" thing brought up was well, are strong point on the criticism side. So if I'm in TOME and I create a character that is a Swordsman whose power is Ice, does that mean I'm related to Nylocke? I don't see why there can't be other Slime users in TOME... Aside from "Well she might like what her brother likes" or "She feels Slime would benefit to her goals" it doesn't make much sense to simply ask that. Perhaps there would've been another way to deduce she was related to Doubling, like the swearing.

My second concern is the language. Now, I certainly have a grasp at the demographic you're pursuing, the 12 year olds that constantly give you a 10 regardless, and the demographic that the more caustic reviewers have a problem with you pursuing. Yes guys, this is Newgrounds, but Chris is trying to create a story that adheres to standard "shonen" archetypes. He's going after this kind of audience that enjoys this stuff. Now as far as you're concerned Chris, I recommend not including such language if this is the demographic you're trying to appease. I'm not saying stop censoring it and let it go free, but don't use it entirely, Adding fuck doesn't add much to the characters, there are other cues to the toughguy persona than simply spouting fuck every five seconds.

My third concern, and this is VERY minor, is that the dialogue flow is somewhat lacking. The characters somewhat sound like the voice actors are just reading off their lines without the feel that the characters are actually speaking to each other.

My final concern, and again very minor, is this story feels like you would have needed to watch TTA to get the overall feel of the series. I want to look at it as though I never watched TTA before. You're working on it, but it still feels like I just need to watch TTA to get the feeling of what's going on, or read any supplementary material to get into the story. I still know nothing about the character's motivations, although this episode made it clear that Kirbopher and Nylocke don't know Gamecrazed enough and wish for him to open up more.

Looking forward to Episode 3, Chris. I once again apologize for my brash issues early on, and I do plan to support the series in any way I can (Such as the $11 donation for the "put a character you designed in TOME as a Background character" and the fanart I'm working on.) and perhaps I should learn how to use Twitter so I don't make the mistake of accusing you of being lazy ever again.

I do suggest however to at least glance some of the people who gave more in-depth reviews, particularly anything related to story issues since your intent is to make a story-based series.

All right..

First of all, your interest gets "piqued," not "peaked." I suppose the latter does make sense but I'm sure you meant the former.

Second, I really get the feeling that there are no rules in this series. The chick didn't see GC coming but none of the other three were particularly surprised he took over the goop? So he can essentially do anything?

Maybe you do have limits thought out that just aren't apparent but from this point but if any random thing can happen at any time it's just going to be ridiculous, like a story a five year old would tell.

YES!!

I'VE BEEN WAITING SO FUCKING LONG FOR THIS IT'S BADASS!!!

...

You know you don't have to have to crank one of these out once a month. Take your time and increase the quality of the animation and writing until it's as close to perfection as it can possibly be. I am a fan of the TOME series, but I feel that this could be done so much better. Listen, the quality is basically a portrayal of what you feel about the series, and right now it feels like you're just doing it because of the demand from the fan base. Feeding the fan base these "one episode a month" shenanigans just doesn't feel right. It takes time to produce high quality flash, story, and humor. What I'm trying to say is if you really care for this series, heed the advice from the others users and make this series something to be proud of. If you don't want to improve TOME, then maybe you should have left it as it was back in 2007. If you are going to continue this, just please put the highest amount of effort in as you can, I believe the series that started everything you've done deserves at least that much. Good luck on your future projects.

Uh...

Although the first episode was interesting, this one kinda was lacking. Nothing really happened here besides the fact that the mansion was introduced. Ok, so it's for a tournament that's supposed to take place in the future and the guy is a programmer and all, but I feel as if it could be executed in a better say.

Kirby and Ny fighting the programmer felt like a cheap excuse the get a fight in. He clearly stated he built the place and no one is supposed to be in there. He didn't even make the first move, which begs the question; Why did kirby and ny feel threatened to have to fight back. In a position like that, I would've just said sorry and excuse myself. Even if I had a strong character and all.

"Jeez, let me sneak into a forbidden area and attack the creator for no good reason..."

That's how that scene felt for me. In the end, at first I was interested in this series. Now I'm a little on the fence. And me being on the fence about a flash that I already know most of what's gonna happen (I saw a good 90% of the original flashes u put up all them years back) is not a good thing.

It's my personal opinion of course, but next episode really decides for me if I'm gonna follow this one through or not...