Reviews for All The Trees

[Originality]

In this one you've done well...

to have fluidity and creativity. Also the theme and style was the same throught the entire flash (which is good). The growing fit the pace of the music and it all worked well with the ideas you've put down. The repetiveness bothered me with the fruit being another fruit, being another fruit, and I'm glad you stopped at two, but if you only had a more creative way of conveying the idea instead of panning out. Also if you changed the mood a tad with each pan it would've been refreshing (simply a change in color used, not style, theme, or anything else that would detract from the cohesiveness.).

The lipsync could have been better, but it is better than most as is. Look at the sixth place in my favorites and look at the lip sync at the credits of that flash to know what I think is the best lip sync that I've seen. It's in profile view, but it's beautiful. "Royal Rumble II Part 2"

[Bad-Atom]

Simple, mellow and very creative

4/5

I've always liked your animations, and once again you've made something creative and unique. The simplicity of the animation perfectly matched the mellowness of the song. Most of all I enjoyed the message behind the animation. It's a breath of fresh air around here...

I only had a few issues: while the lip-sync on the tree was kind of cool and weird, it probably wasn't necessary. And it would have been nicer to have one long zoom back towards the end instead of all the short, halting zooms. You were probably trying to go along with the beat of the song but it didn't feel quite right to me. But really, those are minor issues in the grand scheme of things.

Please keep up the amazing work!

[Barmaglot]

Sooo...

So it was rather good. Nothing really special, nothing really new... And the music was rather annoying for my tste. But it was just a normal good submission. Not a masterpiece, but hs its style. A 7 for this.

[MatthewJDB]

Wow...

Very carming, I thought that was amazing, great idea! The songs not to my taste but it went really well with the visuals and was all in sync with your animation, very good!

[Avngr75]

You did it again!

I just finished watching your other flash for today and I must say I'm very impressed by your work (and your taste in music). In fact I recognized the name Sufjan Stevens and sure enough, he's on a CD my friend made for me less than a month ago. Don't really know any of his work, but I like what I've heard. ^_^ Listening to The Henny Buggy Band at the moment.

I liked the premise of this one quite a bit, and was delighted to see all of the movements to the beat of the song, that takes a lot of skill and consistency! Anyways, very good job once again, I think I'll go watch some of your older stuff!

Although I'll admit, the lack of detail made the beginning a bit tiresome... all that green kinda wears on you... the video really picked up speed when the other colors showed up.

All in all, great job!