At 4/5/16 10:34 AM, Gario wrote:
Mr. Trump proposes letting South Korea and Japan develop nuclear weapons, to relieve America's burden with nuclear deterence.
Not entirely a fan of Trump, but yeah I would be okay with South Korea and Japan developing nuclear weapons.
Please, someone explain to me why they think this is a good idea. I mean, he still has plenty of support, so proliferating nuclear weapons in countries other than our own must seem like a good idea to his supporters. If you really need to know at least one reason why this is a bad idea (there are a whole lot of reasons), ask what Japan and Germany's allegiance was with us seventy five years ago, and whether you think it's be a good idea for them to have nukes then. A country's allegiance can change over time, and if/when it does, you don't want them to hold nuclear weapons.
Yeah seventy five years ago and we haven't had problems with them since. Germany wasn't even that big of a contender against us really, they were mostly harming our allies. As for Japan, we bombed them during World War II and then when they surrendered we made peace with them. We have peace with both Germany and Japan. Besides, Germany has nuclear weapons. Many countries from both allies, enemies, and neutral parties all have nuclear weapons. Different countries having nuclear weapons actually brings forth a form of peace.
Trump is not alone in this idea. With North Korea's testings becoming stronger it might not be a bad idea to have Japan and South Korea, two countries who we are on friendly terms with and don't like North Korea, have access to nuclear weaponry.
Now if you're afraid that this might generate an arms race then I could see that as a worrying, but not a lot. Proper planning and negotiations could prove beneficial.
By the way, shit like this is precisely why I would be terrified of a Trump presidency. This is the kind of thing that could have a globally destructive, even world ending impact, if plans really went astray.
If he's the one doing the negotiating then yeah that could be scary, but it is not a bad idea.