I'll be frank, while this isn't the best 18+ game here on newgrounds, it is still one of the creatively inclined ones that offer humor and actual story instead of straight out sex. Instead of making a tedious summary of what I think, here's a quick list instead.
1. Funny dialogue and interesting characters.
2. Creative direction on gameplay.
3. Seems fun, and has great potential to become something really great.
1. Inconsistent art quality and body proportions (have another look at the pirate blowjob scene and you'll get what I mean)
2. Eventhough its in Alpha, the least you could do before releasing it is to show us a little of how the game would have worked. So far everything was basically just dialogue.
3. I'm not sure inserting historical characters in this game would be a good idea. Let fantasy stay fantasy, ya know? But this is just a nitpcking preference on my part.