Reviews for How-Many-Men have to die?

[AbstractVagabond]

Not surprised by the amount of zeros...

you got. No, that comment has nothing to do with my score. I figured with any political statement movie you're going to get a messload of zeros. If I were to vote based on how much I agreed with you, I'd probably give you around an 8 or 9, but I don't go that route when rating movies. I won't go into why the 4 since the reason I feel you intentionaly ignored it for the sake of concentrating solely on your message. That's fine. I'm sure you had no intention on having a high rating for this anyways. I wouldn't if I did it.

DrPlaid responds:

It's not about the score. Thanks for the review.

[Madman032]

Nice try

I am in the United States Air Force, I just got back from the sand box. Well, yes we welcome anykind of tribute from anyone. Thank You. This isn't quite the best it could be. Instead of random military and political pictures, try following the story of one person, how he(or she) struggled. And don't blame everything on Bush. He can only do his best, and the media can just kiss my ass.

DrPlaid responds:

I agree with you about the media. Thanks for the review man. Welcome back.

[darken8]

I think u must be confused.

i think it is an ok political flash but i disopbrove of the message it is sad tat so many people have died for us but at least we havent lost as many as in ww2 and if we where to pull out no all thos who died would have died for nothing given there lives for nothing. Also war is a good thing our economy feeds off war and plus when we reform iraq we will be first in line to get oil contracts which will help the US and we will be giving the people of Iraq a better life and freeing them from persiqusion. but nice little flash tho i over all give it a 4. ^_^

[Andar]

I agree with the meaning but...

You did nothing but show images. Sure, images are a crucial part of delivering information, but often times you recycled images or they just seemed really disjointed. I agree whole heartidly that the war needs to come to an end. There is a growing dissent among troops for the war that is not getting reported. Many are afraid for their lives, and now its finally starting to scare some of the brass. Its good these images are being portrayed in our mass mediums but we must look deeper. The problems do not lay within the troops but more with Bush and his cabinet. America will soon fall at this rate if these men continue their war of greed and rape. Thats what all wars are though. This petroleum based one is no different. Sure we go under the premise of delivering peace and freedom, but in turn we are installing corporations tied into our government over there. Halliburton has a huge involvement in funding and holding land. Our mere dependency on war and oil is sickening. The very food we eat is contaminated with petroleum based pesticides. Mere "arm chair revolution" will not solve anything. Culture jamming and going out into the streets is the answer. Our time in the sun is greatly depleating.

DrPlaid responds:

Great response. Thanks for the review

[Master-Dee]

It's just a damn slideshow.

Yo, dude, I know people are dying in Iraq and it's a bad thing but I can read about it in the news. I don't want to watch some broing slideshow about the war in Iraq. There is no point to this submission. You say they deserve our repsect but you are showing some of the bad stuff the American military has been doing too. Besides, it's not your war, don't waste lives trying to fight someone elses war.

DrPlaid responds:

Thats fair. Thanks for you review.