Long time since this, but now I see it I have to reply...
At 11/17/05 08:48 AM, Inglor wrote:
At 11/16/05 08:15 PM, Evildwarf wrote:
(...)
Obtaining a flash game or movie without permission is theft and nothing more, it is an ugly thing to do, and perhaps if your flash didn't suck so bad, you would understand how getting ripped after putting an honest effort into something is lame.
(...)
Actually, Inglor, ebaum's is more than theft. In many of the countries that signed the Berna Agreement (or however it is translated into English), the violation of copyright with money involved is an act of *piracy*. I suppose that much the same in the States, for you have a pretty much restrictive law compared to other countries (the software patents, f.i., are indeed illegal in many countries). It's OK to discuss wheter Ebaum or whoever does or does not steal (if Ebaum is or isn't a pirate); as long as just one person with legal authorship of a Flash says that Ebaum has put a copy w/o permission, Ebaum is a pirate, for law states that it is him who has to demonstrate that has the right of copy & distribution (copyright), it isn't the author that has to demonstrate that Ebaum doesn't have it (as some ppl have suggested in other threads).
But I can see no difference between saying "it's OK for whoever (Ebaum & c) to get illegal copies of NG flashes" and "it's OK for you to get illegal copies of Macromedia Flash". Save that the latter would be authomatically considered "discussion of piracy" and would get you banned, removed, erased and terminated from NG BBS, more or less. I think both are just the same case, dunno what the mods do think about it, of if they have thought or are thinking about it, which is very possible...
Anyway, the moral is: never think that an author has less rights than Adobe because is not a multi-zillion budget company. If having a downloadable, free, illegal copy of any copyrighted program in a site for public download is illegal and an act of piracy, the same applies to any illegal copy of any copyrighted flash movie or game. As you said, Inglor, no jokes here. Even if Ebaum closed tomorrow and gave all the money to those authors he's been piracing and raping, he would make them no favor. Everybody plz get over it and stand for your rights, as long as you've got anyone left :)