Better than the first half.
I understand the whole thing's satire. More to the point, I understand the whole thing's satire along the same vein as Piconjo's Legendary Frog and Wade bashing back in the day. And yes, there's a lot of genuine talent put on display in this piece(more-so than the first half of the collab, honestly, though I've no doubt some of the guys went out of their way to do their worst to get their point across), which is why I voted so high.
Unfortunately, it suffers from the same issue Piconjo's work suffered. Namely, it's so much talent wasted on direct personal attacks. You dislike that two people enough that you were willing to put what looked to be days(or even possibly weeks, in some cases) of effort into bashing two people. I don't understand that part.
I do, ignoring the personal attacks, understand and agree with(to a degree) the message behind the collab, though. Newgrounds has, and will continue to, suffer from people following long trends or, in the case of some individual artists, simply riding on previous success until it's dead. It's not really a new issue, though, and is something that has 'always' happened on Newgrounds.
And while I agree that people should display more originality(everyone's capable of it, even the people who're guilty of following their own personal trends), I don't think personal insults are the best way to get the message across. Do they get peoples' attention? Sure. But you stand a good chance of driving away the very people you're trying to reach.