Fair ... no better.
Being a gamer since pong (and a 2D animator), I expected to find some enjoyment out of this ... but all I saw was disappointment. Inconsistent music volume, slow pace, and depicting scenes that never happened in the games (Final Fantasy 1 and SMB) did little to light my nostalgic flame. The only scene that brought a smile was seeing Belmont miss his jump after being smacked by a medusa head (which frustratingly happened as often as battling slimes in Dragon Warrior). Everything else was "I'm learning flash using 8bit sprites" quality. The idea was good, but the author should've been embarrassed to show this to anyone other than a few close friends.