i'd have to say not bad, but it is far from good
The original made me cry the first time i saw it, it was much more well put together, and as a remake, this didn't do it justice. Sure it was more detailed, but it mas just missing something that made it whole and worthwile that the original had. Love the song, love the story, love the original, cherish the thought.
Better than the last one...
I dunno...It was better in the sense that it looks like actual effort was put into this. Problem is...it also looked like you just traced the other guy's pics. Which....I would advise against.....
Still, I liked your changes to some of the different scenes and whatnot! The shading and detail was better too (and the movement)
Glad he let you do it
Ermmm...
I thought the movie was okay. I am sure you worked really hard on it, but I guess it's just not to my taste. I think it's mostly because of how the anime faces were drawn, they look a little out of place when you put it together with that song.
I'll give you a five, no more, no less. It's just my opinion, don't throw a fit about it like you did to the others.
Myeh
The orignial was better. This one was better drawn but it seemed out of place by it. Nice try but you didn't make the team.
Ok, but...
If you're gonna do a remake, you could do something other than just copy the original exactly and add in different scenes or something. Looks to me like all you did was trace the original and add in a tiny bit more detail...
ok, but... the shapes and EVERYTHING are totally different. Theres no way this was traced, moron.