Its silly and kinda fun, though the final level was kinda annoying (Took me forever to find that last muffin) Would be 5 stars but it would not give me the "Oops, My Bad" Achievement or the 48 muffin achievement. Nice idea, fun to play, nice achievements but as I am unable to get the achievements even though I qualified for them, it loses a star.
This game had the potential to be a good one, but it was honestly lazily made. Even I myself could just take a few screens from the MLP: FIM show and place muffins in the scenes.
3/5, could be better.
3 stars for the concept, though.
only 1 medal unlocked for me (for beating the game) tried visiting the achevements page this did not help
I'm taking points off because the game won't load for me on Newgrounds and for sound issues. When I played it on another site, it would sometimes play the level failure sound when I clicked on a random spot (sometimes the noise would repeat over itself 2-3 times). My only suggestion is to try to re-upload it and see if that fixes anything.
Y U NO LOAD!? probably a great game.
See update #3 in the comments. I still have no idea why this is happening or how to fix it.