At 1/8/10 09:01 PM, immigrantsong wrote:
First off, I think I may be alone in the Newgrounds community for expressing this belief.
I find the name of "Ching Chong Beautiful", the game created by The-Swain and JohnnyUtah to be extremely problematic. I've had hostile e-mails written to me by JohnnyUtah and I know for sure I can't get a civil discussion out of him.
While it may be offensive, i think that it should be taken lightly. It isn't like the creators are part of a massive hate group set to destroy Asians. The game was made to play and have fun. It is just the theme that you seem to be upset with.
IF YOU ARE READING THIS, I am not looking for people to jump on me and think that I'm being ignorant and need to "get over it", "stop being a drama queen", or "get a sense of humor", or God forbid, I'm being a "racist" as well. I'm looking for people who agree with what I say. I'm also looking for people who if they don't disagree with me, they will have an open mind and at least understand where I'm coming from.
I'll listen to try to see what your point is, but i can't give any promises.
With that said, this is my main beef with CCB:
First off, the name was something I could not get JohnnyUtah and The-Swain to understand as the former told me that: "i think you're completely overreacting, id already had plenty of asian people tell me they thought it was funny. if that makes me a dick then so be it." The latter gave me a more long-winded explanation to why it was appropriate.
To be honest, it doesn't matter if they find it funny or not. It is a game and nothing more. It wasn't created to show disrespect in anyway, it was all for comedic value. How can you complain about this when movies like "Gran Torino" were in the movie theaters which many more people saw than played this game.
In "Gran Torino" they actually used racial slurs.(i am not going to post them in this thread though)
Arguments that other Asian people find this hilarious or acceptable DOES not mean that racist slurs & imagery are okay. While it obviously complicates the matter and makes people like me be put on the spotlight for not having any humor, it only avoids the simple issue that once again, racism (whether subtle or overt) is still very much real.
Subtle? It isn't like the main point of the game is to be racist against Asians. You seem to feel this way, but it clearly isn't the case. Would anyone complain if there was a game where you play as an American chasing a burger down the road? I don't think so.
A racist slur is STILL a racist slur. And on top of that, the game is loaded with incredibly demeaning stereotypical images that makes the Asian person and culture look like a less-than-desired foreign object.
I can't say i saw any racial slurs in this game. Stereotypes, yes, but i don't recall any racial slurs.
There is an incredibly large fanbase around the world, and a good part of the fanbase are people of Asian descent. Imagine what it's like for them to check out their favorite flash website, and only to have a game featured on the front page that blatantly mocks their identity and their culture. If they protest or question about it, they are immediately dismissed and ridiculed for not having a sense of humor or that they didn't "get it". Incidents like these are repeated over and over and while the mainstream media isn't aware of this, these people of Asian descent become conflicted whether or not it's appropriate to stand up for their beliefs when everybody tells them making fun of Asian people is okay.
No one is forcing them to play the game. If they feel it is offensive, there is a review button on the flash page and they can say what they felt about it. They can also vote on it whatever they want. That is the great thing about Newgrounds, you have the freedom to express your opinions.
I don't want to do a comparison test but if the game was called "Negro Paradise" or "Wetback Wonders", I do not believe that would fly so well with the general public. However, the name of "Ching Chong Beautiful" comes in and nobody breaks a sweat. Newgrounds, like the mainstream media, has allowed the idea that it is acceptable to mock Asian culture and identity, as part of a punch line.
Because "Ching chong" isn't a racial slur. It is just a stereotype that people have for Asians because of their language. Instead of "Wetback Wonders" the game would be called "Hola Hotel", you see?
I do want to argue that I am not one of those guys who think it's totally okay to make fun of white people for their racial identity as well. But unfortunately, any racial slurs for white people do not carry the same negative weight in comparison to racial slurs against people of color.
And that is right? I think all racial slurs should be equal. You pretty much nulled what you were fighting for. You say slurs against white people don't hurt as much as for other races? That is a completely ignorant thing to say.
I understand that Japanese game shows are indeed ridiculous and over the top. JohnnyUtah responds: "Why don't you go spend your time boycotting those japanese gameshows that are making their culture more of a fucking joke than swain or I ever could."
But understand that these game shows IS their culture and just because people happen to find it stupid does not mean their standards or culture compared to another one are any better or worse.
If there's anything I want, a goal, I hope that if there are people who express my same beliefs, that they are not afraid to speak out. I hope there are people out there who at least see where I'm coming from, even if they don't agree with me. I can only hope.
Ching chong chang ching chong.