As much as I should be studying right now...
...I can't help but review this. Sure I told you a bunch of stuff about it already, but I still think I should review this, especially because it's basically a work in progress that is literally bursting with potential. This could really turn out to be one of your best songs, and it probably has the nicest atmosphere from all your songs so far. Also credit me for the name, or else :P.
The composition is great. Even though it can be a bit generic, that's really not much of a problem. I especially liked the melodies of the plucked instrument you used throughout the song, and the abruptness of the plucks made a nice contrast with the smooth, lengthy notes of the choirs, brass and strings. I also really like the idea of adding pitch bending on some of the notes of the plucked instruments, but I suggested that to you before so I'm basically complimenting myself here :3. The staccato strings you used provided a fantastic background by the way. Thought I should mention that.
What I liked the most about this submission would be the REALLY good atmosphere. I can easily relate this to a desert thanks to the melodies you used and arabic-style instrumentation. The choirs helped to give an atmosphere of a goddess too, so I can't say that this doesn't fit with the title either.
Instrumentation was pretty much flawless. Sure, it's a somewhat standard movie score-ish instrument set, but like the melodies, it worked out very well. You also had a really subtle xylophone/marimba or whatever it is (I know you already told me what it is but I forgot :P) which can be heard clearly at 0:28. Subtleties like this give the song that professional, detailed sound to it. I'm also hearing high strings playing along with the plucked instrument. This is also a nice touch.
Now for the transitions. I LOVED them. I agree with Andre about adding more of a buildup at 0:28 and creating a better contrast to the section that followed, but other than that quirk, all the transitions were very smooth. What did it for me would be the introduction of the brass at 1:18. That part literally gave me the goosebumps. Just hearing the choir build up in volume, and then the brass enter in a really subtle manner made my day. Seriously dude, that part sounds just excellent.
The intro is a very nice way to start the song. Rather than starting off slowly and then building up, you immediately began with that awesome atmosphere, helped by the fading choir voices and the shakers. Not only that, but you progressed really well from the intro, introducing element after element. By the way, the ending sucked. It was way too abrupt and there's an annoying clip in the silence at the end. You suck :P.
Structure-wise, this is basically a constant buildup. You must be playing with a lot of volume automations because I'm always hearing the instruments rise in volume which helps create this buildup. I hope that when you continue it, you add a climax, since I'm tired of all these buildups :P. Then, maybe after the climax you could go into a really atmospheric, minimal part, and then slowly begin introducing more melodic elements and continue from there. Anyhow those are my suggestions if you continue it :3.
Now, my one complaint. The production; while the mix was filled up nicely, and you produced this well, the song is really quiet. I don't want to have to turn my volume up just to enjoy the song so I think you should work on mastering the song a bit more. There's too much headroom.
Nothing much to say about the percussion. You used Stormdrum loops for them, like you said, but at least you went and varied the percussion with different percussion fills and rhythms, so I can't complain. The percussion fit well too.
All in all, this is bursting with potential. I hope you can continue this because so far it's excellent. Just work on that mastering, but other than that, this is great and you put a lot of thought into the little details. Good luck continuing this, and keep it up! Feel free to thank me for not ruining your perfect 10 score, by the way :P.
10/10
5/5
-Review Request Club-