Belated NAC Judge Review

It's great for an IDM track, but I wouldn't really call this one uplifting. Besides that, your glitched effects sounded really cool IMO.

<Insert Funny Review Title Here>

Pretty Good....Piano Too loud imo....but I still like it!

Its quite rather excellently swell

elements and glitches are great, lot of idm skills present here, piano melodies sound kinda random to me though, i'd work on those. some small melodic parts were genius though.

NAC Judge

The first thing I hear is the piano and it sounds really forced, a little more humanization could've gone a far way with control over volume and general settings. It sounds really dry and rough around the edges. I think especially for a genre that's supposed to be uplifting.

This might just be me, but it's all too loud and screechy at some points - and I am not feeling uplifted or heavenly by this at all. xD

Especially at 0:54 you've got a bad mesh of sounds that don't match, and still not a fan of the high pitch squeels. XD I read that you are aware of the mixing and that you have writer's block problems, so I'm probably not saying anything you don't already know.

I can still tell you put effort into though though, so don't feel too bad!

5/5!
6/10!

NAC Judge

Cat Fish : Cory MacNiven (Quarl)
This has a very messy and experimental feel to it. In its own category I think this would be very successful, however I find very little of this song uplifting. Rather it is confusing and has themes that are unresolved and presents more minor feelings than major. Your talent is obvious and your time and effort are not wasted, but as far as this contest goes, I feel that this piece was not meeting the criteria.
6.0