Reviews for Guild Dungeons

[makkapakka123]

awesome!!! until...

I LOST MY FREAKING SAVE!!! i know that exp thing was supposed to work instead of a save system, but i just logged in to my NG account while i was halfway through the game, and now have no exp, no buildings, NOTHING!!!! spare this pain for others and make a save system!!!
also, whilst i was playing, i noticed huge improvements you should make:
1. The leaders are so random!!! the first two are a cat and a mouse with barely any damage/armor/health, yet the last 2 are demons with pretty much full damage/armor/health!!! this is totally unbalanced!!
2. THE TRADE/TROOPS SYSTEM..... deary me. this was soooo annoying! cheese for gold was insanely profitable, but clicking 4500 times?? no thanks! buying soldiers/resources in bulk would make this game 10x better!
3. No archers??! No snipers/riflemen??? the only ranged warriors were either insanely expensive, or just plain terrible. i mean, boggins!!! BOGGINS!! plus, it was often hard to tell which troops were ranged or not. if you made it clearer it would help a lot.
4. No way of upgrading anything at all!! this reduced the longevity hugely.
5.No way of knowing what the damage of a sword is, or the defense of a piece of armor is when you are crafting. This means that you have only the description of the item to help you choose whether to craft it or not.

If you upgrade the game, or even make a sequel, then i would really appreciate it if you included even one of my improvements!! thanks

[arXcis]

Excellent game!

I very much enjoyed this game. I, of course, have the same hang up as everyone else did but I recognize the effort. My biggest concern is the redundancy of clicking the mouse 100,000 times. I gave it a 5 and a 10 even with these concerns because the game did compel me to click 100,00 times lol. I'll be looking for a sequel or an updated version of this, sir!

[andynguyen80]

Best Way (but kinda slow) way to make gold

-Build at least 20 lumber house (40 lumber production)
-Wait for the Lumber to go up to a steady amount
-Then start trading lumber for gold
(your gold will go up as your lumber go down then back up)
P.S: I built 30 lumber mill so both gold and my lumber keep going up xD

Hyptosis responds:

Good method!

[MonochromeDecay]

Wonderful

Simply wonderful, very unique, very funny.
I would love to see a sequel, prehaps with an upgrade unit system.

Also, I found a bug with bears eating henchmen that I didn't send. So I would end up with -2 henchmen at the end quest screen and lose 2 henchmen for no reason.

Trade system is kind of annoying. Instead of holding the button, make an arrow to increase or decrease the amount bought.

And like everyone said, a save system would not go amiss. Though resarting with extra resources was a nice way to help the problem.

[TheLumberJackOP]

Sir i love this and it's #2 but i must tell you you SHOULD have kept Shiro he was my favorite leader

Hyptosis responds:

Haha, I'm glad you liked him! I'll try to have him return in future games. :P He was actually a character from a comic I made as kid, back in highschool some 15 years ago.