00:00
00:00
Newgrounds Background Image Theme

MC4HJW just joined the crew!

We need you on the team, too.

Support Newgrounds and get tons of perks for just $2.99!

Create a Free Account and then..

Become a Supporter!

Reviews for "Guild Dungeons"

Great game, but kind of flawed.

I played this for the better part of the day, and overall I thought it was great. However I ran into quite a few problems and issues.

1. Some resources were under/over utilized, for instance I had huge stockpiles of cheese that never was used, yet there was never enough stone till you got all the upgrades then had no use for it.
2. The most expensive items in the game Mushrooms/Gems had no generation source forcing you to buy them, or hope you get lucky on quests.
3. Often the rewards from Quests were not worth the time and money invested in them. I could spend 12000 silver and my troops would only come back with about 4 or 5 gold and 500-600 silver, and you lost more if a soldier died.
4. There is a serious lack of ranged soldiers, and those who are there seem to go un-utilized according to the battle reports report.
5. Even with maximum storage (mules, backpacks, wagons, etc), it seemed like there was never enough space for even the most basic essentials for the quests, then the few items you were forced to leave behind apparently were always the items needed to avoid some disaster.
6. Is it possible to even beat the final quest? I could easily beat the hardest quests with roughtly 50-200 various soldiers, but but after failing the first attempt with my standard setup, I sent well over 1k soldiers with 100 Gnomes, Wizards, Clerics, and Knights each and still utterly failed.
7. And before I forget, just as a suggestion having a way to build, trade, buy soldiers in multiple quantites at once would be a godsend. It took forever to gather trade for the materials I needed to buy all those Gnomes, Wizards, and Clerics.

But despite these, I really enjoyed it. I hope your future games (if you do any more) will be just as enjoyable.

My mouse hates you, yet I can't stop playing!

Very well done game, with some minor bugs, for example, I had enough resources to buy gnomes but it wouldn't let me, I bought a pig farm and suddenly i can buy the 300 gnomes i wanted, so no big deal. Anyway besides the save function that is really needed but you already exposed your reason for it's inexistence, the game needs a better way to buy buildings and even buy or sell resources, this game is capable of killing any computer mouse!
As a function i would probably like if you are thinking of creating more games like this is to know your army's force and the enemy's army force after you fought him, because I had a pretty nice army and it got defeated and I had just done a dungeon with almost the same difficulty and was sucessful.
All and all a great game, hope you create many more interesting games as this one.

Hyptosis responds:

Yeah, I havn't quite figured out the gnome thing, you can fix it by simply leaving and coming back, or buying 1 of any resource required for the gnomes. I'm looking into fixing that bug right now actually. Thanks fo rthe feedback, I'll work on it.

Some pointers

A save feature and/or a feature where you can adjust how much you sell of eatch resource, i end up with around 700000 wood and selling at 1 wood per 1 gold is very very boring and long long time... I would like to be able to sell maybe like 10,000 wood at a time...

NOIYCE

GOOD JOB MAYTE!

Hey

i love this game,but you aleardy handle a save file,to save experience and extra money,is saving handle