nice game
but also is that nevera statuea a refenrence to morowind
Reviews for "Guild Dungeons"
Flawless... almost
This game is almost perfect - from the idea to the design and the interface. Its only problem is the terrible trade system - imagine, how long you have to hold the left mouse button to buy, say, 3000 stones? This pretty much ruins all the fun.
Except for this, the game is superb!
Hyptosis responds:
Yeah, I was trying to code in a way to hold down shift, to increase the trade rates. I'll figure that out for the next one. ^_^
I love this kind of game!
And you've made a solid, simple game. My only peeve, and this knocked you from 10 to 8, is that I cannot sell goods in lots. I seriously have spent the bulk of my time with this game in the trade screen holding down the mouse button.
When I have enough resources to say, buy 5000 stone for a keep when I only have round 200 stone, I should not have to spend 5+ minutes to trade it. If I could just select that I want to convert 125 gold into silver and then by 5000 stone (think that's the math anyway) then that would make this game phenomenal in my book.
Hyptosis responds:
Yeah, I certainly need a faster conversion method, next time I will program something like that. Thanks!
Beautifully rendered simulation =)
Pluses:
Excellent art.
Easy interface.
Good learning curve.
Random events are quite fun.
Some funny scripts.
Hurdles:
Tedious trading method. Input box is highly recommended.
Cheese trade is highly exploitable. Cheese market value should be reduced.
Info on troop expedition would be a minor but good addition to the interface.
Bland expedition. Short animation scenes during expedition would be sweet.
Summary:
Gameplay 9.0
Art 9.0
Script 8.5
Interface 9.0
Coding 8.5
Fun 10.0
--------------------------
Overall 9.0
It's really good, but need some fine tuning
I like the fact that different heroes have their uses, it'd be really interesting if the game could sent 2 heroes at once, since they earn experience any way, I think implementing a level up system for the heroes is also a +
I wish there is more building upgrades or research available to them, like in TD games where you can specialized to do a certain things.
The only complaint i have is why after the research, you still need so much $ for the expedition, I think the expedition fees is a little bit too high scaling them down would be better imo anyway.
To say one thing, it's really a great game spent 3 hours without noticing, good job