Reviews for Clab - Pigpen Vs Vinstigator

[Carefoot]

PiGPEN:
+Lil C opening/exit laugh

Vins:
-whack flow, just not a fan of the eunciation and style, sounds like a white guy trying to sound like a cholo
-'straight doped up' failed flip, proving to be a sober prohibitionist and the exact moment he lost my vote.
-can't think of anything less gangster then Smash brothers

Pigpen:
+has that Madness like swagger from verse 1 with the Lil C laugh echoing out of his last verse

Vins:
better then first verse

Vins is a good rapper in theory if his lyrics and eunciation weren't garbage. If he learns to write in the present tense, loses the cholo style (just use your regular voice) and then he'd be a upper/middle tier rapper.

However Pigpen is what makes this track re-listenable Vins verses are forgettable meanwhile Pigpens verse is the better written, more funny and has more replayability.

Swine Pencil gets my vote.

[DescratedSentinel]

I expected more from PiGPEN. Granted some of the fat jokes were pretty funny but he needed to bring other material. Never really been an issue before, but I think some of the things that Vinstigator brought up were totally random, the Hopsin mention really stuck out for me. Also Vinstigator's flips were pretty weak (4 chins to 4 dicks?!!! / Gonna eat you lyrically). I also think Vinstigator did a poor job researching especially considering he was up against PiGPEN, I heard no references to his infamous flash games? what about V-TECH rampage?

Overall I'm giving this to PiGPEN because his lyrics were much more original and witty. But props to Vinstigator, his 2nd verse was much better than his 1st.

TL;DR

Vote: PiGPEN

[JakobePaulobe]

It doesn't feel like PiGPEN really tried at all in his verses, but then again I can never tell if he's trying or just trolling everyone with some of his battles. I feel like Vinstigator won this one, he came more personal and had a much wider range of punches. My advice would be to stop saying "motherfucking" so often though. Usually sounds corny like Butsaay said, and it just unnecessarily takes up space.

PiGPEN was entertaining though, don't get me wrong. I just think Vinstigator earned the win here and put more time into it.

[Poniiboi]

First of all fuck Big Red and big ups to Vlash cuz this beat is awesome.

Now pig. Cmon.

This was the weakest performance I've ever heard from you. To think I'd been listening to your JEsus song and shit over and over again looking forward to this year's competition because pig has personality and was gonna do some real shit. Fuckin disappointment.

Also, it's obvious the fucking votes for you are alts cuz who else would take the damn time to capitalize the PGPEN and write the "i" in lowercase except the fuckin person who came up with it? Yea sure, not definitive proof, but I'm going off common fuckin sense.

Vinstigator for the hands down win. Fucking disappointed in the pig.

[Cyberdevil]

Nice. Pigpen's verse starts off smooth, great play with words, though a bit repetitive with the fat - don't eat me. Vinstigator brings in some more intensity; follows the beat, packs raps. In the second part it again feels there's a bit much filler in Pigpen's verses, though the wordplay is great, less repetition would be an advantage. Vinstigator packs more of a punch with that attitude and edge too, even if the words don't always flow. Close call overall; I'd say Vinstigator wins with intensity. Great beat btw; the sound effects fit in perfectly!

-cd-