Reviews for Wilderness Guardians

[Splatty]

A few points

I have nothing against the game but the fat that you based it in the game rather then your own universe shows a lack of effort and imagination. Also this is nothing like the runescape world. There are no giant battles and no one raids town... you can't raid towns. I can understand that you really did try to make a sentimental piece but unfortunately rather then deep and confronting it became corny and annoying. No offence intended but your voice is too weak and you sound like you have a blocked nose.

But after all this your flash skills are impressive and the choice of music was great. Maybe you should stick to those rather then writing the plots and voice acting

But after all this your flash skills are impressive and the choice of music was great. Maybe you should stick to those rather then writing the plots and voice acting

VelvetDarkRocks responds:

Thanks for the criticism. You said that I was not very imaginative, and you also said that I was not true to the game because I created a new world. This is a contradiction. While based on a game, it is quite original, don't you think? And I believe I have written in the credits that the voice acting was not my own.

[SolidSpartan]

Well...

Agreeing with Greig, it doesn't deserve front page, or to be blammed. I know you are asking to vote it aside from the game, but I've played runescape. This video isn't like the game, not exactly. Good animating, though.

[Psycotronic]

sorry...

sorry, I didnt like it that much... next time please take the time to plan out a story board... and watch other more succesful movies to get a sense of "timing" because to be honest the way you did the cuts and paced the movie was quite boring to me. Im sure with just another day or two in editing you could turn this into a really good animation.

ohh, and one more thing, people arnt going to rate you low because its based on runescape, but in fact they will rate this movie much higher...

[archont]

OMG DIS WUZ SOO KEWL LOL

LOOK FAGEX DOESNT LET U TYEP UR PAWRD OMG MIEN IS ******!!!!!!!!!1

TRIMMING MIT 2 RUNE 4 FRE LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!

GIEV ME GOLD SUM1 PLZ!!!!!!!!!

WUT BOT R U USNIG???????

Without the above, runescape is not runescape.

Stiff animation, wrong colours, and runescape. Below average.

[bmxdroid]

meh

Was that a robot talking in the beginning?