i'm not sure if i like this
Graphics
There are a lot of creepy-shit-paintmade-pictures and thats why you get only 6. Next time try to choose the better ones.
Style
I like the concept but the realization is bad. 7.
Sound
Yeah. That's it! 9!
Violence
I don't remember but take 3
Interactivity
Was there one?
Humor
hmm.. 4
And the overal.. Paparam.. 6.. That's it.
Choose better ones? Do you even understand the concept of a colab especially aimed at EVERYONE. You know what, I love all th citrues even the 'not so good' ones because everyone had a chance to join in, I think considering the majority of reviews were brilliant your review and reasons for, are a bit "I'm on a high horse" next time join in and see if you can bring the graphics up eh?
hats off to all who worked hard in this collab.
The song was brilliant and I liked the end-reveal and the peak animation, but there just didn't seem to be as high a standard of creativity as in the Red Line.
I really liked Memb's - nice use of custom brushes.
There were a few other pictures that were really technically accomplished. However, many of them seemed like pictures that had little or nothing to do with the mountain and would work equally well if the mountain was replaced with, say, a house, an abstract plane or a grassy field or whatever.
It was somewhat enjoyable to watch though and hats off to all who worked hard in this collab.
Cheers, the quality of some of the entries was lacking, but we specified from the start that everyone could join, so we kind of shot ourselves in the foot a little bit. But yeah Memb's entry was cool.
Could be better, probably needs a bit more time...
I agree a few of the points that cannibal made. (BTW, canibal, the artist you're referring to was eternal decent, I believe)
Some was good, quite a bit was bad... Too many people went with stick figures, and a few even pulled it off pretty well, but the overall was still sub-par. It was good for a watch, but I doubt that it's going to go very far.
*2*
I think you underestimated a lot of it, there were some entries which were no where near the quality of others, but it was a community project and allowed everyone to join in, no matter their skill level, and i wouldn't have changed it :)
The people who werent particularly good had a chance to be part of something, and I'm glad they did, because they are as bigger part of newgrounds as everyone else :D
Too many horrible pieces, a few good ones.
Like 75% of them were made in MS Paint out of stick figures. What's with that? Even though it required no art, I also liked the Dora one.
It was no where near 75% and besides I won't keep repeating myself, everyone with any skill level could be part!
wtf?
thats stupid. Most of the stuff there wasent even drawn by them and some of them was draw on paint...
Erm... I really don't know how to reply to this. All submissions were drawn by an artist. Therefore I'm just gonna mentally note your words as invalid.
Have a fantastic day though!