At 4/20/16 12:38 PM, BrolfThePaladin wrote:

At 4/20/16 12:25 PM, DeftonesFan665 wrote:
But a part of the first post in this club said this:

"If you enjoy giving constructive feedback to others and you wish to join the club, simply respond to this topic with something like "I want to join".

So I'm pretty sure I'm doing the correct thing here.

Well, this is actually true but who is stopping you from reviewing the stuff other people post here?

It's not stopping me from reviewing the submissions people post here, but I just want to officially be a part of the club, you know?

At last, the first post says in the bottom

"Can I join the club?
- We are ALWAYS looking for new reviewers and EVERYONE can join the club, so the answer is yes "

I never saw this, so my bad, I suppose. I just wouldn't feel like I joined a club if the creator or someone who runs it didn't accept me themselves. That's just me, though. I kind of need clarification, I guess, haha.

You are lucky then, Ectisity should be there in...pfff...few hours? Dunno. Around this time he's mostly on. When I go to sleep. Hm. I love my timezones.

At 4/20/16 11:56 AM, DeftonesFan665 wrote: I'd like to join the Review Request Club, please.

Great! Welcome to the club :). It's true as you said, as I need to know which people I have to give notifications to, and because I need to know which people are a member of the club in order to make sure all review requests are met, I would like it if people made posts saying "I want to join" like this. Ofc everyone is accepted, but it gives me a better overlook.
Thanks for joining, and have fun reviewing :D.

- Ectisity, RRC

At 4/20/16 12:52 PM, Ectisity wrote: Thanks for joining, and have fun reviewing :D.

- Ectisity, RRC

Thank you so much!

At 4/19/16 12:09 PM, DididdProducions wrote: I just joined NG and I need help getting scouted. can you look at my song please?
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/680181

Sure thing. :)

• 

  Quicksand

  by Drewpy

  Electronic fast-paced theme

  Song

  Dance

  1,738 Views

  PLAY

Feedback would be appreciated! Also, I know the mastering is severely sub-par on this one.

Here's one of my songs!

• 

  Creepy Spirit Remake

  by Im4Hero

  Electro song with EDM beats

  Song

  Dance

  1,234 Views

  PLAY

It's an electronic song with some dance beats.
Not asking for the most detailed and polished critique (but feel free if you're on a typing fever).

• 

  Summit

  by Pi0run-V

  Progressive House with electro elements

  Song

  Dance

  2,284 Views

  PLAY

My request.

• 

  Vegetables (WIP)

  by TIMETRAVL

  Some track I made

  Song

  Dance

  759 Views

  PLAY

hey i would like to get feedback on this...
I'm ok with the structure of the track but i'd still like to get feedback on how I could improve the mix etc.

As usually I post my music here.

• 

  Respite

  by Felocai

  Melodic EDM i think but i'm not sure tbh

  Song

  Dance

  946 Views

  PLAY

Hallo everybody--I'm a noob noob looking for a scout. Thanks to the person(s) who review!

My song's called 2d Scrolla

Hey, new person, here with a song I finished today.

• Unpublished Submission

Hope you like it!

• Unpublished Submission

• Unpublished Submission

At 4/30/16 12:05 PM, Enzo07 wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/681621

At 4/30/16 12:06 PM, Enzo07 wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/681653

I'll review both of these for ya.

I thought i knew how this stuff worked, but now I'm not so sure:

Are we supposed to prioritize the "new request" in the previous big post, or the loose ones that comes after? Of course it makes sense to review some of the loose stuff (like when you've reviewed literally everything else, not naming any names... :D), but I thought we should mainly focus on the stuff in the update post.

At 5/1/16 11:43 AM, TheJawns wrote: I thought i knew how this stuff worked, but now I'm not so sure:

Are we supposed to prioritize the "new request" in the previous big post, or the loose ones that comes after? Of course it makes sense to review some of the loose stuff (like when you've reviewed literally everything else, not naming any names... :D), but I thought we should mainly focus on the stuff in the update post.

It goes like that. Our leader here puts all requests of the week together in one post. We review them. Well, as our leader is also just human, he doesn't got every week time.

Well you HAVE the opportunity to review stuff that comes in just as you wanna BUT(T) you just can wait and review them when they're listed in the weekly post.

And as you may know, we norwegians are actually pretty 'cool' guys (ha haha...pun) you also just can pm @Ectisity for any questions you have. Or just ask here. I think, I'm 'til now the only one next to the leader who answers questions...well as far as I can, there's stuff I don't know. I'm not almighty 'y know :)
I think the better word would be Albert Einstein but I think u know what I mean.

Well as I said in a post before, nobody is forging you to request stuff or don't request stuff. But I think you are right, when you review stuff, you should focus FIRST on the main post and THEN on the loose stuff...even when you have stuff in the main post you don't like. Give people advice and give them your meaning. That's why we are here. Give creators our opinions and tell them what they could do better. Don't be shy. Also if your ears bleed cos someone fail'd. Everyone fails. So just help 'em. Maybe some ppl are either aware of bad stuff or are just lazy bastards hehe :D

At 5/1/16 12:39 PM, BrolfThePaladin wrote: Maybe some ppl are either aware of bad stuff or are just lazy bastards hehe :D

Cool, thanks for the clarification!

Hey i could really use some helpful feedback on this track, mainly on the mix but also arrangement would be useful too.
Thanks in advance. i would like to think my mixes are improving but you never know :)

• 

  Joystick Junkie

  by 8-bitheroes

  A new track from my 8-bit EP ''Joystick Junkie''

  Song

  Video Game

  3,169 Views

  PLAY

Yup, it's just as Brolf said.The point of the update post is really just to make the club more structured. This club is all about reviewing, so whether you review the requests in the update post or just the ones that are loose (which will be included in the next update post anyway), it doesn't matter that much. Most important thing to me is that you review because you feel like you want to and not because you feel like you have to.
Thanks for you Contribution :D.

-Ectisity, RRC

At 5/1/16 03:04 PM, Ectisity wrote: Yup, it's just as Brolf said.The point of the update post is really just to make the club more structured. This club is all about reviewing, so whether you review the requests in the update post or just the ones that are loose (which will be included in the next update post anyway), it doesn't matter that much. Most important thing to me is that you review because you feel like you want to and not because you feel like you have to.
Thanks for you Contribution :D.

-Ectisity, RRC

Absolutely no problem dude :)
I'm often @home at weekends because of my videos I need to cut so I got pretty much time on the hand. xD

Can I get a constructive feedback on this:

• 

  Knock Up

  by Demonic-Overmind

  Knock up

  Song

  House

  1,439 Views

  PLAY

• Unpublished Submission

At 5/5/16 02:37 PM, Enzo07 wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/683056

reuploaded

I would like to get some feedback on this thing, I´ll write review for you (on music) in return

• 

  May Vibes

  by 5TanLey

  A bit harder hitting uplifting piece

  Song

  Drum N Bass

  1,119 Views

  PLAY

Hellow <3
Here's two things I'd like to be reviewed if possible ! =3
If it's not possible, well just review the first one ! X)

• 

  Destiny Acceptance 2

  by MysteriousPresence

  This track was made for Khud0's game "Nary" ! (Blue Album)

  Song

  Cinematic

  994 Views

  PLAY
• 

  Cosmic Versus

  by MysteriousPresence

  WARNING : THE ENDING IS A LITTLE BIT WTF ! :3 (Blue Album)

  Song

  Cinematic

  882 Views

  PLAY

By the way, It's been 3 weeks since the last update, we should maybe make it ! I can help if you want !

At 5/8/16 08:47 AM, MysteriousPresence wrote:

:, we should maybe make it ! I can help if you want !

Yup, it's coming tomorrow togetherwith Reviewever of the month :)

At 5/8/16 02:11 PM, Ectisity wrote:

At 5/8/16 08:47 AM, MysteriousPresence wrote: , we should maybe make it ! I can help if you want !

Yup, it's coming tomorrow togetherwith Reviewever of the month :)

Oooooooooh... *_*
Fancy ! X)

I would like to have your thought about this one :

• 

  Piano Shuffle

  by sebastien01

  A Shuffling Piano Composition

  Loop

  Jazz

  3,397 Views

  PLAY

: And also this one

• 

  Drowning Bot!

  by sebastien01

  Sub bass drum'n bass audio story

  Loop

  Drum N Bass

  2,102 Views

  PLAY

If you have a sub, does this song sounds good with it? Because I've put some sub bass drums but I don't have a good quality sub, so I mind if it sounds crappy or not on you audio system :P On my headphones I can hear everything relatively well, but when it comes to sub bass, it needs a good quality sub as yours to judge.
Thanks to anyone taking of his precious time to give his opinion about these songs! ;)

At 5/8/16 02:11 PM, Ectisity wrote:

At 5/8/16 08:47 AM, MysteriousPresence wrote: we should maybe make it ! I can help if you want !

Yup, it's coming tomorrow togetherwith Reviewever of the month :)

The Reviewer of the month. Oh boy! I wonder who will it be! :D