Great graphics, great music and solid puzzles! Only three stars because it just didn't quite feel like it all came together to me...
Could be improved a lot by: i) tweaking the experience to cut out unnecessary delays (e.g. the giant axe and shield between every screen was really unnecessary; the girl takes a long time to shrug, which is annoying when you want to try a bunch of items out somewhere; and you could cut out some of the unnecessary 'puzzles', like having to place the compass on the table - a few things like this just seemed to me to be creating needless obstacles); and ii) adding some kind of story / dialogue to give me motivation to move through the game. I know there's the cut scene at the start, but it didn't give me much to go by, and for most of the game I felt like I was wondering around trying to get things to interact with each other, but not really having a sense of why on earth I was doing any of it. e.g. even just setting up at the start three main goals - need to get a ship; some bait; and a net... would have helped a lot.
Very nice piece of work though - like I said at first, all the core stuff (graphics, musics, puzzles) are really well done.