Reviews for My Little Pony: Cupcakes

[dahalonut]

My soul...

This... this killed my soul. The fanfic made me nearly throw up, but this... this was just so much worse. Just seeing it animated made it so much worse...and therefor so much more horrifying.

My only complaints (if my dead soul can have one) is that there was no voice-acting, and the lack of some scenes (despite the key scenes being present) that slightly killed the loyalty of the vid. If this were made more closely with the story, and had voices, it would truly make my nightmares complete.

9/10

[MortalKombatFan2]

Solid work

It was pretty well made, although you should have included the part where she wears Dash's intestines as a scarf

[Acekillcard]

Intresting!

I believe it was a good enactment of what happened in the story. I personally love this story for its macabre theme and a feel of Ponyville not being as perfect as Faust portrays it as. It gives it almost a normal feeling almost human! Pinkie makes a hell of a Hannibal Lecter!

[Mahziel]

Quiet

That was an awesome flash. But no voices when mouths can be seen moving and the music didn't quite fit so yeah 9/10.

If you ever felt the urge to redo this I'd love voice acting, longer, more gore. Then I would throw money at my screen until I find a paypal link or something similar.

[artistwithouttalent]

Good

You said that you hadn't read it, and given that criteria, or even w/o it, it's a pretty faithful adaptation.

@RYUHAYABUSA5009 In the story, the secret ingredients for her cupcakes were pony innards, and the story (along with this film) depicts her harvesting that ingredient. Thus, Cupcakes.

@CyperAleksi you aren't the only one. I believe that, since she seems to have little concept of the long-term implications of her actions, we view her as sick and insane, and speaking for myself, I actually felt sorry for her. In the original story, I thought the violence sometimes went over the top (as in humorously so.)

Animation was OK. Scenes where they are talking could be better.
Music: No comments. Nice choice.
storytelling style worked well here. I think Pinkie's expression is a bit overstated, but that's just me (I would have gone for a more "Party of One" look, though it seems like that was what you were going for, with the straight mane.)

Overall this is pretty much how I envisioned it when reading. I like the details, with the writing on the wall (no pun intended.) It's good.