Very good
The music and every single sound in the flash movie is so beautiful. Nice graphics and good overall flash movie. The visual effects are great too with lots of detail to the graphics. The animation movements are good and can be improved just a bit with some more sketches in the frames per movement, but still very smooth and nice. Keep it up and make more!!!
-Serio
Wonderful
I really cant judge this. Everything was smooth and pleasing for me . I loved the music at the start and middle and end, who ever wrote it is very skilled.
The starting effect ,i couldn't even believe you could do in flash.
I cant really judge 2d animation but this is a one of a kind i just had to say
I loved every part of it.
Just one thing off subject you will alway get people bitter about your animations when there far far far superior than others.
Example
I won a contest on who could make the smoothest sphere and export it to dts format. 50 down votes bitching 3 well dose's.
I cant say much more i don't have the experience even to judge this.
Good work 5/5.
Winterwind - Hey, first person to kindly notice my (small) contribution. Thanks for the mention. Tom Brokawwwwww
i really hope
the review before mine doesn't get deleted it probably will
anyways everyone did a really good job of course the best collab on newgroundssz
Poetic in all senses.
I love how some people can't grasp the idea of having an open mind. Just cuz they personally don't like certain aspects of it, they decide that those personal negatives overpower the more important messages of the flash. I mean down voting it because of the music? That's prolly one of the worst vices newgrounds has. Regardless beautiful flash. I can tell it took a lot of time and effort.
P.S. I read Theo Art's comment on the iPhone shuffle: for one I think this flash still garners a #1 daily win, but the shamelessness you describe is also a global thing. Yah this flash is beautiful, but a lot of the people that come here are only teens or younger and fail to weigh poetic beauty and humor/action/etc. on the same scale. This applies to a lot of things in the world. I'm not gonna say i'm an exception cuz i voted both flashes a five, but i acknowledge that the vote is for different types of creativity and they both entertained me very well.
Awesome
"I really don't want to sour the 10's being thrown about, but there are some areas that need to be addressed. First of all there was no need for nudity, sure sometimes there is something surreal about showing something and having nothing sexual about it. The nudity in this collab gave it a sense of childish pollution. While the story line was clear in some areas, it was a bit vaque in others. There were also a few other areas whose frames were either fewer or a bit laggy. All in all, at least I didn't try to blam it. I will be keeping an eye on all of you and see what becomes of you, sincerely John Collins. Ps: I know how love can hurt, I almost gave it up because of the knives thrust into my heart. Ps: Ps: I suggest making a music collab of the song Sing for Absolution by Muse next."
"All in all at least I didn't blam it"
Whatever that guy's problem is I think it's jealousy. You all did brilliant work. The Nudity( which wasn't even bad) only added to the seriousness of this project. The art was amazing and is an inspiration to the work I will be doing in flash in the future.
I look forward to seeing more of your brilliant work.