Reviews for A Piano's Testimony

[ErikMcClure]

Superb

I keep coming back to this song over and over and every time the melody seems just that much more brilliant. The rolling feel of the instruments and how everything comes together is extremely well done, but I think it could use just a small boost on the higher frequencies, and the middle of the song might have benefited from some very subtle hihat hits and possibly some very low and quiet drums to keep the percussion going. It'd have to be pretty delicate to maintain the superb atmosphere you have going here, but if you could pull it off this would be the essence of perfection.

9/10
5/5

Gravey responds:

Interesting, I'm boosting the high frequencies between 5-8 db (It's on a curve) because it is so lo-fi sounding if I didn't. If I raised them anymore the song just wouldn't sound natural. So I really can't bring the high end up anymore than I already have.

I thought about adding a studio kit to this song, but when I did it just sounded ridiculously out of place. So you are on the same track with the high hats comment as I was when I was in the middle of composing this. But you will just have to trust me when I say the studio kit simply sounded odd in the mix. ;-)

Thanks for the review.

-Gravey-

[AnockDragon]

:) nice

sweet song

Gravey responds:

Thanks.

-Gravey-

[DeadlyShadow]

Pretty good

Reminds me of this fantasy game. Nice piano~

DeadlyShadow

Gravey responds:

Glad you liked it.

-Gravey-

[brainboy1]

very good

i liked it i think this deserves #1.

9.5/10

Gravey responds:

Thank you very much.

-Gravey-

[nuketrooperx]

yer!

its seriously quite good when it gets into it it eminds me of some kind of adventure but the reason y i made it an 9/10 not a 10/10 is bacause well its not my type but its not ur fault well thats me!