Reviews for Punt a Penguin

[making-fiends]

didn't like the obvious rotoscope parts but...

i won't get on your case... yes i will.... compromise just a little.

honestly i feel although time consuming and boring anyone can rotoscope, and it takes away from the style of the animation, except in things like play where it is the base idea, and is centered around it.

other than that good job, message was a little weak but it's for NG so deep meaning will be lost here. I also feel that the only kind of endangered animals with support groups are the visually appealing ones, won't find to many for the endangered species of tape worm (not that i'm upset about that).

you made punting the penguin look to fun... and as if the penguin enjoyed it's little ride.

other then that good movie, i'll give you the 5 maybe get a last minute front page

[Edubdizzal]

this is a nice message to everyone

Good job on lookin up facts about the pengin I would of never know. :)

jmtb02 responds:

Thanks edubdizzal, I am glad you liked it.

-jmtb02

[lazybum1]

goto the comedy section tovi..

was a real good flash, very nice graphics to.

[Tovi-Noname]

Well How 'Bout That.

Uh... after school special, anyone? Not really funny at all... informative... sort've... but... not all that funny...

~Tovi Noname~

[tomullus]

wtf?

...so i understand that you really want those 2000$,but .....

1.What the hell is the reason of that penguin dying????!!!! kicking??!! Be specific...
2.How is a mayor of an in-land city supposed to influence the penguins??
3.I think that people give you such high ratings because they feel kinda guilty... like... they feel it they say something bad about this they're gonna be "anti-life","rascist","fascist","untolerate" and whatever.
4. Did you really analised some charts or numbers or did you only made this according to some stupid "Focus" or that website? I think you just don't care to know the truth.

The graphics were good, but you get an overall 1 for not being precise and not taking the task seriously(or maybe being too naive).
Whatever.... Peace

jmtb02 responds:

I didnt even submit this for the contest, please do not judge my entry based on money... I know the people at CFGS because I won the first contest, and I did work for them over the summer.

1) Obviously, you cant put 2 and 2 together. Penguins are dying due to climate change, it is in the first few frames of the film. Ice mass = gone when the world heats up. Penguins lose their homes and eating locations.

2) Mayors can enforce public initiatives that cut back on bad emissions, which increase the warming of the earth. In many ways, it will cut back pollution and help the urban environment.

3) Well, they dont have to vote, do they? And man you are vicious. I make a flash that is good in nature, and you immediately put it down. Carry on the NG spirit and stereotype man.

4) Yes, in fact. Unlike you, I did some research before sputtering my mouth like you did.

I cant believe you gave me a 1 for not being precise. Next time, email me, and I will make an animation that is EXACTLY what you WANT. And the name calling. Geez. Grow up.

-jmtb02