Boo
Half of your drawings are direct copies off Miller's work. Congradulations on being able to trace, and animating difficult eye blinking movements.
Reviews for "Sin City Tribute"
The music ruined it
That music did not fit at ALL with this. Overall I'm not really sure how you could make this flash better, no offense but there is nothing much to it really, nothing at all.
Mediocre
The scenes were cut together well, good flow. I hated the music. It half ruined it for me (once the "singing" started). I thought it would've been a bit more dramatic without the SFX (like the gunshot sounds and etc, the visuals themselves were... not that bad), it kinda took away from the movie. Overall, it was fair. Not fabulous, not terrible. A few tweaks could've made it much better though.
Not bad...
It didn't seem like there was very much too it. The visuals were solid but it looks like you just took pictures from the comic. The music didn't seem to fit very well either. The animation wasn't much itself either. Here's an idea (and I'm just tossing it up in the air). Why don't you make a comic with your own pictures and story line with the same simple animation. At least you'll have some points for animation. I've seen this done worse before but it's still nothing special. If you haven't actually read the novels I highly recomend it. Solid effort and congratulations on front page. I swear I'll get there someday...
excellent
It was very good Sin city is a great movie however this could of been a little longer but other then that it was great.