Reviews for Sin City Tribute

[a7knight]

I just had to comment on this one...

Wow. I really want to know why this submission made it to the front page. Here's the reasons why this wasnt too good:

"Took three weeks to finish, all drawings were drawn on Flash MX"
I think you meant to say traced. As someone else said before me, you just took the stills from the comic book and traced over them.

Then you just threw some main quotes from the movie in there as well.

And to make matters even worse, not only did this song not appeal to my taste in music, it didnt even fit in this movie. The type of sound which belongs is a creepy kind of industrial sound... just like the theme song from the movie.

Sorry, but you made this sweet movie look terrible. Honestly, if i saw your flash "tribute" before i saw the movie, i would have never wanted to see Sin City in my life. Good thing i have seen it allready, cuz it is a great movie. :P

[TheGreenUFO]

weee

i liked it! that movie was awsome! :D

[TKDdan]

Wasnt that in the comic?

I havent read them myself, but ive seen the comic versions of the movie characters on ads and stuff. Arent all of those people you 'drew' used directly from the comic? Please someone tell me im wrong, but i dont think i am, Im pretty sure those figures in that flash were not 'drawn' in complete originality by you. Either you took them directly, or you traced, either way.... wtf.... Please reply this if im wrong, i dont want to point a finger at someone if they really did it themselves..

[Marco]

ok///

i didnt really like that...bad music...very bad music.:(

[S-W-A-R-M-generation]

.... ok i guess

i just had 2 major problems, i didnt understand it and the music.. ugh that sucked. the singer was yodeling/ barfing and i dont consider that music.