Reviews for Sonic Tribute Collab

[Hedgefox]

Good work... but lacks something

Don't get me wrong, I liked the collab, but it could be done a lot better.

Instead of all the classic scenes where Sonic fights with Shadow and turns Super Sonic (Boooooring...), where Super Sonic fires a beam of energy (Booooooooring x 2...) and those ripped images from Sonic X (that's not boring, just pretty lame), each of you could have done a little story, like the author who made the piece where Tails rescues Knuckles or Shadow that fights the G.U.N (those are the 2 that I liked most BTW).

I didn't like the drawings of some authors but I understand that Sonic & Co. are pretty difficult to draw, ever more difficult to animate, so I'm still giving a 9 to the graphics.

Keep up the good work, although I would appreciate more a story rather than a small collab. Oh and please, if you do one, don't put any Megaman or Matrix cross-overs, those things pretty much suck :D

[hungrysucko]

u are wrong!

i totally disagree with u ericsuvillian. Do u kno tat shadow can control space and time and his chaos control rocks!!

[Danath]

Nice collaboration job.

Its always interesting to see the styles of different artists joined together to make one piece of art.

To the children who don't understand what a collaboration is... good thing school started again for you kids hunh?

This is normally where I break down each section and give critique, but thats a little tough to do with so many artists. So all I can say is that this was a good team effort and keep it up.

[Kaika87]

Some of em good, some not so much

Like the last couple guys said, some of them were good, like Bit_master, Slowshadow, and HyperactiveYouth, some were jaw-drop wow like Doom_Fox and Ultimate_TH (actually, my favorite was Ultimate's, just for the flawless animation and getting the feel of shadow. That and Doom_fox's parts put together make me hit replay). In short, this collab had some great and ok animators, but the couple bad ones detract from the overall quality of the movie.

[dofusman]

tres bon

tes desin son cool mais d'autre laisse a desirer