iono
it was good everything exept for what matterd most.. the story line..which was crap good work on everythin else
Reviews for "Star Wars Episode 3: ROTV"
Vinstigator responds:
Well thanks. Sorry u didn't like the story
Not so great.
It was kinda stuipid. The voice of Vince was annoying and the moogle talking like an internet guy saying omg and other crap like that was kind of annoying. But the part with Vader and the sith lord was cool.
But overall it wasn't that great.
Vinstigator responds:
It was meant to be stupid.
Not very funny
Just wasn't that funny to me.
Vinstigator responds:
I rather get reviews like this than the ones like "OMG u sux!". So you got straight to the point without being abusive, I like that. Sorry you didn't think it was funny. Can't please everybody
It is clear much effort went in to this 'toon....
.....and it is clear that, in addition to some in-jokes, there is a great deal of "virtual" bad blood between you and some other animators. Thing is, for the average avid NG consumer, such reflexive commentary generally is not highly engaging.
Your voice work quality is very high! I would love to see that level of quality, and a non-self-aggrandizing plot applied to other projects. In-jokes and slams are amusing enough, but when coupled with "easy-way-out" sprite animation, it bogs down. Good luck to you!
Vinstigator responds:
So the hate brought the score down, eh? Well I agree I should be focusing on my more serious projects. But I just wanted to fuck around and have some fun :(
more effort needed
it was going okay but the last seen killed it. you shouldn't of just used the lines from episode 3 you should of got someone to impersonate the voices. it was weird having different words in the subtitles than in the accual movie
Vinstigator responds:
I'm not the first one to have different subtitles during un-edited audio dialogue. MANY people have done it.