interesting..
I didn't think it was too bad.
Hell, with a little more time and effort, it could have been even better.
Reviews for "Have a Happy Birthday"
hmm..
interesting.. i liked the ending. "everything will be alright", human confidence. it's interesting, to say the least.
Good start
I thought this was really good and random (and i mean random in a positive way!) It kept me interested all the way through. I love these kind of short animations, so keep up the good work!
it was ok
you've made quite good effects, and I don't mind watching these short pointless movies, I'm more interested in the way you've developed the story, how you did it, and just the use of your imagination. Ofcourse there are a lot more interesting necessities when animating, but as for me, I just like looking at creativity. Keep going, everyone needs to start somewhere.
Skills.
You've got skills my friend, use them wisely.