Good, but not "CharlieZero-good"
Graphics are good, very detailed and shading is done very nicely. I loved your razorsharp outlines too and nice use of colors, I esspecially liked how their skin color was a bit tanned. Also cool who you had written "The Bard's song". At the very beggining the art was wonderful, but till the end it really lost much of greatness and feel a bit rushed. Also in the end when he starts to sing the bridge "But the bard's song will rem-aaa-aaaiin...", synching was done very poorly and alot of the overall impression was lost, since it's a very important sequence of the movie. Also his redhaired wife was a bit badly drawn, it was quite obvious that you had rushed her.
Sound is great, Blind Guardian is an awsome band and the song is very powerful. Maybe you ould have a link to the website at the ending credits.
Interactivity was ok, even if not necessary. Great you guys had the lyrics, something I acctaully missed in the original. Maybe you could be able to toggle the control bar though. (like in ebolaworld cartoons).
Style, style is great. The mood is great and it's just wonderul to watch. Afterall it's just a remake though, and to make something with a reference is a lot easier then creating it from scratch. Call it a tribute or whatever, but honestly it's just an exuse to get ratings on other people's work, much like all the Madness "tributes", that have been flooded the portal lately. If this was your original work you would have gotten a ten for interactivity.
Violence was good too, even if not necessary for a good flash. The blood splatter scene was done very nicely and with almost as good as the original. Nice you had a bit different graphics too in this scene. The greay haired dude's sword was a bit short though.
Overall it was a solid flash, and remakes can been fun watching. Also, "CharlieZero's the Bard's Song" is my alltime favorite on NG, and I expected a lot from this animation. It was a very good remake, and you guys have added stuff to improve it, and the drawings are occasionaly wonderful, but It doesn't have the same -MaGiC-, as CharlieZero flash have.