This is without a doubt the best Carmel game so far.
The case was logical, the jokes were funny, the characters interesting. I love how Sherlock Holmes comes to suspect everyone whom he encounters. It's especially ridiculous and funny with the newspaper boy. The nobody here joke was good. I guessed murderer from the first attempt, it was not hard. After that I got a reason to replay the game and accuse everyone else, leaving the true murderer last resulting in a hilarious ending scene.
Only reason this is not 5 stars is because it is still ultimately a short and a bit too easy game.
Great game, as usual. But what was the ticket to the hotel for? It jumped to the conclusion befor eI had to chance to try it anywhere.
The Friends reference is awesome.
Love the "Friends" reference lol