Good!
Animation/Graphics: 6/10
The art wasn't very good, to be honest. There was little shading and rough, thick outlines. However, the guy with the eyepatch was drawn better, so it was obvious you learned as the flash progressed. However, there were still too many gradients. Just out of interest, how long did it take?
The animation was interesting. Although you stuck to tweens most of the time, they were effective and expressed movement well.
Storyline/Concept: 5/10
Well, the plot is pretty typical and dull, but it still worked. Considering you didn;t use dialogue, you carried it off very well.
Audio 8/10
The music worked really well, syncing nicely with the animation, and the few sound effects were good.
Overall: 7/10
A great start, but there's still a lot of work to do..I'll be looking forward to the next one. :)