Wow man good stuff

Originality: 5/5
Wow very original great in graphic style and plot style.
Graphics/Animation: 3/5
The graphics are well...
Better than I could do, but there is a lot of better stuff out there. You could use some work with your main character make him more of a serious character, or add some more detail to him. Average. 2.5/5
The animation has plenty of movement and keeps the view into the movie which few people put into their animations, but the animation movement itself lacks. but overall good. 3.5/5
Sound/Voice: 4.5/5
Great use of sound with the graphics. 5/5
Ambient noise and music. I simply cant place my finger on it but it is lacking in something sorry I can't be of help. 4/5
Plot: 5/5
Even though I didn't get the ending, the animation sure "moved" me. It was very original and the way it flowed was amazing. The mystery shrouded in the creek was very well keep, well... mysterious.
Overall: 17.5/20 = 8.8/10
The graphics all in all seem amateur, but the story and how it's put together are professional. (you're a good writer i bet)

Final Score:
9/10 (4.5/5) (rounded up cuz it was awesome)