Surprisingly, I loved it!

Usually when I see flashes that aren't exactly hand-drawn the best nor has the best lip-syncing, I usually give the author crap for it but the fact that it was anime, was American Idol themed, and had great music brought the score waaay up. I loved it a lot. Every anime fan should watch this.

is this a parody...or...?

um,...but i liked who won......naruto should have come in 2nd though, he could have used the hammer

but

i thought naruto was good

Surpising good

It was kinda hard to tell who some of the characters are (the first place winner was from pani poni dash I think) but it's still good

(by the way, were the first and second prizes pictures from Adventure Quest?)

Not bad

The mouth sync was off during Sasukes performance and it was hard to tell who some characters were. Effort went into this obviously, so I congratulate you on that.