Happy Birthday Grace!!!
not much I can say about this, only that it appeals to certain people.
there was no point, but then again, a point isn't always needed. the animation was moderate, the song can appeal more to other people, but i didn't care much for it, but i didn't count it against you. the thing that brought you down was the lack of action. it was a kid just standing there moving his mouth... but i have to admit it was cute. i digged the whole noir style.
...that you didnt get a ton of harsh reviews. I put a film about my baby girl being born, and while some people loved it as they did this (its a different breed of movie on NG), OTHERS persisted to make fun of my family and call my baby obscene names. You are in the clear probably cause you animated it rather than use actual pictures. Other than that you did a good job, and it was cute as hell.
awww that was cute.