At 7/19/09 02:41 PM, MJTTOMB wrote: To B-flat minor?

Normally when people just say Bb, there's an implied major

in most cases yes, but music jargon is notoriously imprecice.
To transpose is to change the key only, and never to change mode, therefore a melody either stays minor or stays major reguardless of what key it's transposed to. As such, one need only mention the new key without having to specify major/minor for a second time.

anyways, here's my offer, I'm not sure If I'm entirly satisfied with it, I thinking about adding a 5th variation with full orchestra, but I'm not sure it would spoil things. I reckon i alslo coudl beef up the up tempo bit with strummed spanish guitar and maybe some harmony for the flute/whistle,

It's voices for string orchestra and various soloists, including in one variant, a Drone/reed instrument.

theme & variation for Newgrounds guy
http://soundcloud.com/puppet-show/james-
garvey-theme-variation-for-newgrounds-gu y

Please also email this to: nathan@nathanallenpinard.com

I tried emailing ant attaching but my internet explorer quote: "stopped working"

will a yousendit email suffice?

At 7/19/09 06:57 PM, aurongroove wrote: I tried emailing ant attaching but my internet explorer quote: "stopped working"

will a yousendit email suffice?

You can send the link if you want, no need to send the file.

Count me In. I was waiting for a good opportunity to get started with music making on a computer. I can't wait to get this started.

Sounds pretty interesting, I might give it a shot or two, but if I cant be able to finish it before the first of August I wont have time to enter, if that is the case, could I enter as a judge? I have plenty of knowledge about sound engineering and music theory, so I guess I could help you...

Btw, perhaps I got the wrong mp3 file but isnt the key of the song F major?

At 7/20/09 01:25 AM, JohnnyFrizz wrote: Sounds pretty interesting, I might give it a shot or two, but if I cant be able to finish it before the first of August I wont have time to enter, if that is the case, could I enter as a judge? I have plenty of knowledge about sound engineering and music theory, so I guess I could help you...

Btw, perhaps I got the wrong mp3 file but isnt the key of the song F major?

D minor is the relative minor of F major. They both have 1 flat, but they are by no means the same thing.

I'm in if I can be bothered, I have no idea what I'll do with it and it may end up sounding extremely bad.
But I'm in

At 7/20/09 09:46 AM, jewcurls wrote: I'm in if I can be bothered, I have no idea what I'll do with it and it may end up sounding extremely bad.
But I'm in

I found the theme a great rock to lean against, it's well written and aslong as what your doing "agrees" with it you'll not produce anything aweful.
sometime your givin a bad theme, and you really have to bend over backwards to fit it into any musical context.

At 7/20/09 07:04 AM, MJTTOMB wrote: D minor is the relative minor of F major. They both have 1 flat, but they are by no means the same thing.

I agree, but harmonicaly speaking, the key of the song isn't D minor but F major, otherwise it would have a C sharp in it.

In my opinion the relatives in music are useless, scales should be completely based on harmony because otherwise it causes confusion...

At 7/20/09 12:59 PM, JohnnyFrizz wrote:

At 7/20/09 07:04 AM, MJTTOMB wrote: D minor is the relative minor of F major. They both have 1 flat, but they are by no means the same thing.

I agree, but harmonicaly speaking, the key of the song isn't D minor but F major, otherwise it would have a C sharp in it.

Harmonically speaking, D minor wouldn't have a C sharp unless it was harmonic minor. Natural minor has natural C as it's seventh note.

Also, D minor and F major are both the same scale, only with different starting points.

At 7/20/09 09:31 PM, blackattackbitch wrote:

At 7/20/09 12:59 PM, JohnnyFrizz wrote:

At 7/20/09 07:04 AM, MJTTOMB wrote: D minor is the relative minor of F major. They both have 1 flat, but they are by no means the same thing.

I agree, but harmonicaly speaking, the key of the song isn't D minor but F major, otherwise it would have a C sharp in it.

Harmonically speaking, D minor wouldn't have a C sharp unless it was harmonic minor. Natural minor has natural C as it's seventh note.

Also, D minor and F major are both the same scale, only with different starting points.

Precisely. They're the same notes. It's just the Ionian and Aeolian modes guys. Seriously, it's pretty simple.

Hehe. Greek terminology <3

While you guys are busy theorymumbojumbo-ing I'm recording an a cappella rendition by ear.

HA

At 7/20/09 11:30 PM, tingtonger wrote: While you guys are busy theorymumbojumbo-ing I'm recording an a cappella rendition by ear.

HA

Good for you. While you were doing that, I was already done my submission, making minor changes, as i will continue doing through the end of the competition.

heh.

Good for you. While you were twiddling buttons I was slaying dragons with my hands behind my back and singing into the microphone with my butt. :D

Count me in, I'm just wondering if we can put another theme over it, or make a counter-melody (I'm not sure if it's called that way in english). And I'll put a 12 bar shuffle improvisation section in the middle of the song, if it isn't too much...

At 7/21/09 01:07 PM, camoshark wrote: Count me in, I'm just wondering if we can put another theme over it, or make a counter-melody (I'm not sure if it's called that way in english). And I'll put a 12 bar shuffle improvisation section in the middle of the song, if it isn't too much...

I have no problems with either of those ideas.

Great I've already done the intro and the middle, I'll probably be done by tomorrow.

Excellent contest idea! I've been wanting there to be more creative contests like this :)

Will all the submissions be viewable at the end? I'd really love to hear all the different ideas everyone has for it. To me that sounds like one of the most exciting parts of this contest!

And what's with the bad vibe in the posts so far? This guy has given us a fun chellange to do together and discuss. Let's have some fun with it :D

I'm giving it a go in 4/4 time, but currently having a bit of trouble getting the motif variation to sound right without lots of changes to the theme. I might have the changes, but play it again in 3/4 time later on.

I'm in

I wanted to do a more classical thing with it, but after talking to my buddy who's coming back from basic training soon, I decided to go with an army march type of feel.

It's gonna be in 4/4 time, I'll have it done in a couple days.

I only have notation software, so mine probably won't win, but I'll give it a try anyway, and maybe it'll give others ideas or inspiration.

I really love this idea of an orchestration contest. It's a great theme, too.

If you guys want, I can maybe give honorable mentions to the entries I think have potential all around.

That'd be awesome! And possibly some constructive feedback on what the honorable mentions strong and weak points were.

hey guys, i dont really post much at the forums.. but im constantly posting music.. this seems fun so im working on my entry now.

im using the actual melody line without changing it, its not that long either.

will post soon when its finished

I have 2 entries so far. Remember, you must email you entry (or a link to it) to my email at nathan@nathanallenpinard.com with the subject: MUSIC CONTEST (or CONTEST)

including mine?

Yes please.

At 7/23/09 03:02 PM, nathanallenpinard wrote: Yes please.

no no, what I ment was, have you recieved 2 entries including mine? I emailed it to you about 3 days ago.

I have not. Could you try sending again?

I have sent mine, so hopefully you have recieved it!