Wow, you're such a good singer. You know how to hit pitch really well, and I think with some practice, you could become a very good singer easily (things like rhythm, intonation, quavering, etc. are secondary to understanding how to reach pitch!)
I liked both sections, but I think the second half was slightly better because, being further away from the mic, you had some more freedom with your voice to do stuff like quavering (2:26, 2:52) and more adventurous stuff (2:07, 2:49). Also, the reverb towards the end of the second half sounded awesome. One thing I'd say about your piano is that, personally, I find it interesting when the melodies played by the piano differ from those sung, so you have even more melodies playing at once!
Hearing this, I want to hear you sing something in a language you're more familiar with! Hopefully, your cranky neighbors will move away soon so we can hear you sing more. Great work!
also 2:22 voice crack lel
Hahha, you came back to review this anyway XD
It's funny how most people have been complimenting my singing. It's probably just a smart illuminati way of encouraging me, but I guess it worked. In the future, I will upload more singing, I guess... But probably lazy singing like this, with not much practice nor great mixing :p
As for the pitch, I'm pretty good when it comes to the main melody. Just in case, I played it as well. But if I'm sining with others, I need to really focus in order to get tenor/bass right (mostly, because they're pretty boring to remember though).
Nice catches at all the points you mentioned! 2:22 was 100% intentional though XD
"I find it interesting when the melodies played by the piano differ from those sung"
=> This, I'm super bad at. I'd like to be able to play different rhythms and meodies while singing, but it's IMPOSSIBRUUU!!!
I might sing "Vem kan segla förutan vind" sometime. Davy Jones Theme is probably "stolen" from this. It's so similar, and in the same key that I find it hard to believe that it's 100& accidental :)
Thanks for the uplifting review!
Lovely piano-playing, as always! :D Don't worry - I'm not going to leave. Not even close. It's kind of funny how when most people sing in English, even if they're from the U.K., Australia, etc., I usually can't tell the difference between their voice and that of an American, yet I can sort of tell you're a European by your singing voice, which is cool. Anyway, I don't think the singing was nearly as bad as you made it out to be in the description. As a pianist, you naturally have a superb since of pitch accuracy. The main thing that made the vocals sound less-than-superb for me was that they wavered a lot, especially whenever you changed notes. Maybe some breathing exercises would help? Another thing is that you might've just been nervous when you recorded this, or you just didn't warm up. Still, I think your voice wouldn't waver as much if you were more confident in your singing ability. Did you practice at all? It helps to hear that you can sing it well before you record it. :) Anyway, I definitely admire your ability to play the piano and sing at the same time. I could not play the cello and sing at the same time...ever. XD I'd love to hear more songs with vocals from you, LSD! Keep it up! ^^
I chose this song because the piano playing is actually pretty easy, luckily. I just can't play something complicated while trying to sing :p
Yeah, in this song it's pretty easy to tell that I'm European. But I can sing just like your avarage American too, if I want to :p I wasn't aiming for any specific accent here, which is probably why it gets a bit messed up in such regards. The redneck version that I didn't upload though!
Well, you say I've got good pitch, but then you notice that I'm actually playing the melody with the piano as well, in order not to stray away XD
Partly, that's so that I can play the rhythm more easily, of course.
My pitch hearing is unusually bad for a pianist though, probably because I barely ever practice that :(
I DID waver a lot. Partly, it's because I had the microphone pretty close both times, so I couldn't sing too loudly, or it'd clip. But I needed to have the microphono on a high volume-receiving (whatever) level, so that it'd catch the piano too :/
And I definitely would need breathing excersises too! I have a weird form of asthma, which may or may not impact, but either way, I've got pretty weak lungs :p
I didn't really warm up either though, and this is definitely not the song that I know best. The problem is, I'm horrible when it comes to remembering lyrics D:
So I only know like 10 songs or so by heart, while I know snippets of thousands XD
I wish I could play much more complicated things on the piano while singing. And you shouldn't worry! I can't play the Cello at all ;)
I aslo wish that I'd find a time and place to practice singing... By myself and online tutorials, like I learn most things. But we have paper thin walls here :/
You'll probably have to wait a while before hearing more songs with vocals though!
And wow, you're really wuick at this! You almost caught up already, somehow 0.o
Only three tracks more to go.
Thank you, a lot. Reading your reviews fills me with a warm and fuzzy feeling inside :3
I like how much expression you put in the singing. That really does make this track pleasant to listen to.
I prefer the first version.
I agree - Singing while playing piano is hard. o_o
Thanks for the mention! ^^
Why hello, and thank you :)
Interesting; most people ahve preferred the second version!
No problem! But it annoys me very much that the link html was removed from descriptions; now I have to go through like 50 of them and do corrections -_-
One of my old favorite songs...
The redneck version was amusing to listen to because you got the accent down at parts... actually I don't mind it and prefer the second more than the former... maybe because you were having more fun with it.
Did you mention what microphone you were given?
For the first part, you hit most of the pitches but the intonation is a bit awkward. But overall it's alright...certainly better than what I could have been able to reproduce with my voice
Coincidentally, I sent you a pm the exact second that you posted this review (ackording to Newgrounds anyway). Interesting.
This is a song that I find myself going back to from time to time.
The funny thing is, that wasn't even the redneck version! That was just a slight southern accent, but I tried going full redneck on one of the recordings that I didn't upload :D
The microphone I got is a Rode NT-USB http://www.thomann.de/gb/rode_nt_usb.htm
I've found that it's very good, especially considering the price!
You're not good at singing either? I kinda figured that you are for some reason, but eh.
Thanks for leaving a review!
not bad for the sing you have made sure i think you are better as musician but it not bad what you have done :) one thing sure you are better than me to sing :P
and good job to have 200 fans :D that means to me you make good stuff
p.s: i am sorry for the last time i didnt know what is pads
Thanks a lot for all the compliments!
Don't worry about that, pads is a pretty specific thing, so most people don't know about it ;)
Please contact me if you would like to use this in a project. We can discuss the details.