WHOA DUDE THIS IS CRAZY AS HELL
Reviews for "Planetoid - Chapter 4"
Dude, don't remove it it's great and to get daily 4th place is a good thing! I had to hurry my animation along too to get it done for RobotDay but it was mostly the soundwork that needed doing. Just take your time and complete the animation and release it again at a later date. You could just replace the file on this one but then it won't get seen by many people. It's good though, well done!
Fate responds:
You've pretty much hit the nail on the head with all of my intentions and reasoning. I may leave it up, if it still manages to do well with the competition, and update it later. I felt it could've pulled better than daily fourth if I had managed to finish it properly.
...I don't know where to start from...
A lot in here wasn't really of my taste to be true.
I think that such a long animation shouldn't have just music... specially This type of music, which doesn't have good term lyrics and/or strength to bring the best feeling out of the animation itself.
Personally, I think that was the main mistake you made.
Not that I don't appreciate the work done and the time spent (God.. almost 3 years..)
but I also noticed it was always the same... the music kinda got me into trance so I really didn't pay much attention to the animation to be true, but I tried, and the animation was also very monotonous.
Thing here is, please, for such a project like thisone, try finding someone who can provide sound effects and see what it looks like without music, Or try with another music which won't get people into trance and then make them see the comments and go: "uh well.. most voted 5 so.. here, I'll vote 5 too".
You know?
I know you were self taught, but truth is, when you animate, you don't just draw frame by frame. You have to Accept Every Frame you draw and not just go like "Uh yeah this is fine.." when you know it can be done way better.
Hell I loved the effects you made, that was pretty cool and all. If I could Ever animate like this I could die peacefully, that's for sure. but I ain't no animator, If I was, I'd point Way more up than this, And I know you can notice what I'm saying here.
I noticed you wanted the whole animation make the viewer to feel this was a very awesome animation, you can tell by the music and the effects put into it, the fast paced and the slow down at the end.
I have to admit I don't like this style either, so my score might come more from that point of view. The storyline (which I haven't been following) was going pretty much with the animation, but you really kicked the good stuff out of it at some points... this is because (I Think) of the music. But whatever, You animate the way you like, I'm no genius to tell you how to, I'm just saying what I felt and saw here.
I hope to see a Master piece from your skills some time soon.
And I also hope this helped a little. sorry if I offended you in anyway, Just trying to help. I know how exhausting it is to work on an animation, and get it if this really isn't helping you at all with the mood.
Fate responds:
I agree with you on the feeling part. This animation doesn't have the emotions that the previous chapters had, but they all served a purpose, including this one.
I understand your opinion on the music, but I strongly disagree. It's ALL about the music. Music can create the right mood instantly, and I feel no one is ever seems to be able to use it correctly. This song was chosen because of its major contrast to the previous chapters. We find, quite suddenly, that p37 (the robot) is in way over his head, and everything is happening way too quickly.
That may not have come across just yet, however.
As for.. accepting frames..
I know I'm not the best animator yet. My character designs leave something to be desired, and I don't have the perfect flow in frame by frame yet, but I'm learning. This was all an experience. And I'm happy with how it turned out.
I'm not sure what you mean by 'me trying to make the viewer think it's awesome just because of the music choice'. If that had been the case, I don't think I would have spent as long animating it.
And I never kicked any good parts out of the story. It took me a long time to choose a song that I would be able to tell the story with. I actually had a completely different song until the day this song was released by F-777, and I felt it was perfect.
Animations don't need to be like every other animation. Just because this one doesn't have sound effects, doesn't mean there's no story.
I appreciate your opinion and detailed review.
This is my opinion and detailed response.
Thanks :)
Woohoo! Aliens in space! Woot!
Interesting music choice. Well animated.
Fate responds:
Robots :P
Robots in space.
Although you do see an alien bird for about 1/5th of a second.
really fun animation, with an old school vibe I thoroughly enjoyed, nice work.