Reviews for Sonic VS ??? Unfinished

[Ericho]

It might be good

The problem is that you should not really submit tests to this website. It might not be so much of a test as a preview (as the title suggests) but it's still an incomplete movie and it doesn't cause much anticipation. I think it's kind of obvious who is going to fight Sonic in this. I believe it's another version of Sonic. A pity you could have not had the character shadowed or anything. I think this actually wouldn't be that bad of a full flash.

The lines drawn aren't too bad, but the spritework needs more. It seems like you could make this better by having a lot more action. I will always regret never knowing how to give a submission a "Replay" button so I can't criticize you for that. You should look into someone who knows more to understand it. It's a bit too short for a preview too.

[megamanexe2006]

Too short

This is too short, even for a preview. It was nicely animated, but it deserves turd of the week for being so meaningless

[Johnny-Deg]

Exedor is right.

This isn't Testgrounds! You can't just say "please rate my part of a thing that I haven't finished yet, and may never finish so it'll be an unfinished thing forever..." You have put us in a bind, and here's why:

This "animation" is a fragment. It's a piece of what could eventually be turned into a story, but for now, it's nothing more than a part or a bit.

There have been lots of flash parts and bits coming thru recently. Newgrounds used to not put up with this sort of thing at all. The problem is not if it's bad, but rather if it's good. When it's bad, it gets a low score and gets blammed and is forgotten and gone. Done.

If it's a 'good' piece, then people get confused and may pass it. The problem is that then we've got a fragment of a piece of a bit of a flash floating around newgrounds forever, and what's the point of that? That's not what Newgrounds is for.

Newgrounds is for FINISHED items. It's not good to have fragments floating around with people going, '...WTF is this??!?' when they find it.

Finish your projects and THEN submit them.

Shockstar9000 responds:

I know. My bad then, i'm used to submitting trailers before the work is complete to show others, what im working on. Next time, i'll submit the whole thing when it is fully complete.

[papermario300]

a great animation but to short and loop

this really deserves the turd of the week if you want to add a flash to newgrounds you should end and make better give 2 only for the animation and the draw but is too short the trailers is to poor and loop if you want to add animation or game you should finish all the work

[Wegra]

Doesnt seem like it was worth it to be honest. So nah