LOVE IT!
Well, the title says it all, but to go more in depth...
Graphics- 5/10: The weak point of this game...But I'm not a graphics whore, so that's not a detraction. If you make another in this vein, though...Try to make characters and not just the little pictures, if you can.
Story- 8/10: It's a basic, no-frills story: "Good guys, go here and hurt the bad guys! They have shiny things..." And it works.
Sound- 10/10: The music, at least for me, captures that 'heroes journeying into the unknown dungeon for fame and fortune' vibe. Also, the slicing, whacking, and other assorted combat sounds are appropriate.
Gameplay- 9/10. One of my questions was: "How can I cleave with a spear?" but other than that, it was awesome...I never lost a battle (Though I lost my fighter on level 5, and my wizard in the final battle...Shouldn't have lighting-ed the field.) The New Game+ rewards were VERY nice...^_^
Overall- 10/10. I loved the whole thing...I hope to see a sequal sometime in the future...Fave'd and 5'd.