Reviews for earthsick

[Bobitoz]

perspective

As it seems all that you are looking for are good reviews I'll try to refrain from sounding to critical.

The overall presentation was good, it flowed seamlessly with the music, and the animation was smooth.

My gripe was that it all had a rough look to it, not in an intentional way but in an incomplete way. The words (which is the bulk of the flash) looked very digital. I would of liked to have seen more with the line (the other major component).

I would like to see more atmosphere and camera effects. The foundation of the flash has been laid. Don't stop, keep fine tuning to really make it something worth watching.

[xhero-009]

Yah

I thought it was ok,but you need to add more emotional animations with what the guy is saying not just the lyrics,i could've got into it more if you woulda animated what the guy said,i really didn't like the song but i'm not gonna take off points for that.i hope my review was helpful

[ImagineBall]

I LIke the Timeline lyrics effect u gave it.

It reminds meof the movie catch me if u can. how the intro to that movie was. ITs not bad if i was u on ur next music video add more stuff like go to a differnt part to a small clip then go back to teh time line lyrics or something. peace

notorious responds:

lol this is the only music video i'm making in this lyrics/line format.

Thanks for the helpful review though!

[Mirobu]

ugh.....

i hated the song. the guy singing it has an awful voice, and the lyrics are just stupid.... The animation was good enough though. next time u do somthing like this pick a better song. Seriously that was the worst song ive heard in months and im not even that picky with music :P

[hardluckart]

OMG, some one on the intarwebs didn't like me!

dude, this was OKAY.
no, it wasn't that graphics intense. there were more words than images, let alone actual animation...which was kind of annoying. what little animated movement there was (gears, flying birds, eyeballs, lightbulbs, etc.) was pretty simple and not all that impressive. repetitive vertical lines flying by for 30 seconds is BORING, not artsy or cool. i didn't like the song much either, but thats just my opinion. overall, it was not bad....but really not that great.

plus- its a bit presumptuous to just ASSUME you'd win an award if you had been front-paged earlier. i personally don't even think this deserves front-page, and i would be a bit more appreciative that it made it there at all. stop being bitchy and whiney; if you can't handle negative reviews- don't submit on newgrounds.

notorious responds:

1. I'm not complaining about the reviews

2. I'm not assuming i'd win an award if it was front paged earlier, infact i assume quite the opposite.