4/10
Graphics - 9/10, nice graphics.
Sound - 7/10, decent sound, but some fuzz and voice level imbalance, and lack of acting skills for alot of the voices.
Animation - 4/10, I just didn't like your animating job, you didn't put enough time into most of it, and it made it look jumpy/overly amaturish combined with good graphics, the emotions shown in the characters animation as well were as dull as the voice acting.
Storyline - 0/10, Honestly, Eggman hits Sonic with a baseball bat? That's garbage. The idea was great, but the way you through it together seemed lesser that what it could have been. You should have had something more realistic happen to Sonic, or not even show what happened, just have sonic wake up on the table, and why would eggman just let Sonic leave as a dog? I didn't know if you were being semi-serious or trying to be funny, either way it was terrible. The ending sucked, it was too short, and unfullfilling.
Overall - 4/10, You obviously put effort into this, but It doesn't deserve 2nd place, or to be on the front page, or at least in my opinion.