Reviews for Clans at War

[Darklore]

Oh where do I start first?

Considering the opening drawings are either tracings or some other graphic program work from pictures off of the Dark Sun settings books and boxed sets, when the artist did his own work, it was mediocre at best. As for the violence. gee how many heads have to come off in these? And why is someone impressed with that? That's just dumb. Your style is lacking, I see no story whatsoever because you don't even have a dialouge with the characters in the trailor. The sound was ok, but at least edit the sounds static and pops out. I know my system is just fine because I tested soon after watching this toon and nothing was wrong. And the animation was choppy to stiff, but if you are still learning the trade of animation that's understandable, no one starts out pro. Well keep trying kiddo!

StenFLASH responds:

Dark Sun? never heard of it. People should realise that all the good things have already been done and that it's inevitable that everything has similarities to something else.

[ink2468]

it sucked

make a move to it

[ZainAngeldust]

Ok, look...

All this BS about giving Brom credit is making me sick. You can't just copy someone's art, give them a little credit, and expect that it's ok.

First off, it's not your own version of his art, it's a traced drawing, so it's not original.

If you were making original drawings of his characters, that would be ok, but instead you are just making copies and claiming they are new characters.

That's like if I were to trace a pic of Spiderman, alter it every so slightly, and claim I had created a new character named Arachnoguy. I'd catch the same shit your catching, because I'd be ripping off someone else's art and ideas.

However if I were to create all original drawings of Spiderman and say I was doing a spin-off flash series based on the works by Marvel comics, that'd be more acceptable.

Giving Brom credit doesn't justify it. And I'm sure if he finds out, you'll probably wind up having to remove it because of copyright purposes.

Just give it up already. Appologize for what you did, and give it a second shot with original art. You obvious have talent using flash, but no one is going to take your seriously if you're using someone else's art and, indirectly, trying to make it your own.


- Zain

[Lpoolboy]

I was bored shitless this was crap

Ya that was really crappy.

[SuicideClock]

Go see Archaos' fitting "tribute" to this movie

its at
http://www.newgrounds.com/po rtal/view.php?id=35618