Reviews for Tinman

[Yiffy]

uhm...

it was like 30 seconds... and it didn't make any story line

BlackmarketKraig responds:

Hmmm, yeah.

Maybe it was a little short. I did think about that, but I often get complaints that my movies move too slow, so I thought that I was probably wrong about this being too short.

Thanks for reviewing!

[fish-factory]

hmm,

oooooh, you were so close to making an interesting point, nice try. Good animation though. the blinking of "empty" was pretty blinding and annoying.

BlackmarketKraig responds:

Sooo close I can smell it. Maybe next time... :)

Thanks for reviewing.

[kdbalthazor]

Nicely done

One question; if it was sad that it did not have a heart, isn't that an emotion?

BlackmarketKraig responds:

Thanks.

I don't know if there is a way to define emotions at all. It's kind of an abstract concept in the first place, I think.

Yes, sadness and desire are certainly emotions any way you slice it.

But being conscious of the fact that you are incomplete is more of a gray area...

But the way I view my movie is that the robot is unaware that he actually already possesses emotions but is unaware of it.

Thanks for reviewing!

[Michelangelo]

solid movie

i like the thought process
that was being put into it;
however, there wasnt that
much of a connection between
the animation and the comments
you made in the authors notes.
despite the incoherent pacing
of things, the animation was
nice and i really like the smooth
color palette; though the animation
was simplistic and bland. the visual
style was unique and had its own
artistic flare. the music was fitting
and really enhances the mood of
the setting. just conisder next time
to actually have an actual and
consistent theme or idea.
score: ***
Mj

BlackmarketKraig responds:

You have a very
interesting way
of spacing out
your review. I
don't really
like to make
authors comments,
I am not very good
at explaining things
without direct enquiry.
Thanks for reviewing.

[XwaynecoltX]

Robot crazyness

Wow this one is really intense love the dark visual here and that opening scene with him walking and the music was perfect there was a small story in there too making this a fun film here and you have presented a nice element and a great submission here, Fun entertainment here with this film and it has robots in it so thats always cool and you have outdone yourself here.

~~SUGGESTED IDEAS~~
no changes needed but do make more like this

~X~